News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by hari_seldon_ on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:08PM (#16394334)
Agreed. The dominant strategy seems to be to undercut competitors until they are driven out of business, and then you can raise prices. However, raising prices then gives opportunity for a new ride-sharing service to come in and say that they can compete by offering lower prices for a period of time...
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by crdoconnor on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:07PM (#16394939)
This is a strategy that has "worked" in transportation markets before. This is what the post-privatization 1980s bus wars were all about in the UK.

A few companies won out, consolidation happened, unprofitable routes were dropped and prices rose on profitable routes to a level where bus riders could be more reliably tapped for profits - largely by monopolies and duopolies.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by clairity on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:30PM (#16394566)
yes, that's how capitalism is designed to work. the window in which you can make outsized profits is meant to be temporary so companies can't just rest on their laurels.

it's beautiful when it works.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by EpicEng on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:42PM (#16394693)
Capitalism is not "supposed to be" a race to the bottom and then the emergence of a single, monopolistic entity. That's far too simplistic. Price and value are a huge component of capitalism, yes, but the general idea isn't "price below what is sustainable by taking in massive amounts of funding until all of your competitors are sunk and then increase prices."
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by zanny on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:27PM (#16395177)
Capitalism is absolutely supposed to minimize costs, that is how competition works. It is more a consequence of economic reality than a function of capitalism that massive vertical integration and economies of scale can let market-spanning monopolies form.

But as others have said, unless barriers are put in place (economically natural like mindshare or opportunity cost or artificial ones like bribed legislation) the monopoly can't abuse their situation without opening up avenues for new competition to arise to compete with them.

On one hand, capitalism is obviously not optimal - a monopoly is only held to a price ceiling of what the most nascent newcomer is capable of. They are almost always able to take home the profit of their scale and integration even in the presence of competitors. On the other hand, the only way historically nations have battled this is to micromanage a market to guarantee enough strong entrenched and scaled competition to keep there from being a decisive market leader. But over time all markets trend towards that kind of centralization.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:00PM (#16394863)
There's nothing about this that will allow a single, monopolistic entity to emerge. There are probably hundreds of "Uber-ripoff" apps out there by now. Sure, as long as someone is willing to pour VC money into it and give people subsidized rides, sure, Uber can kill off contenders and stay dominant. But the second Uber starts raising prices to extract monopoly profits, someone else steps in and undercuts them. You can probably get started in a city for a few $100k, or even less if you have an existing operation of some sort you can leverage.

The low-barrier-to-entry nature of this market is pretty much perfectly suited for market conditions to prevail and ride prices to stabilize quite near their costs.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:34PM (#16395248)
That's essentially the argument NC has presented for why Uber is not sustainable.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:55PM (#16395500)
In that case they make very bad arguments, because such an equilibrium would be expected to be quite stable (although Uber might not be part of it).
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:57PM (#16395523)
If Uber "is not part of the equilibrium" then that would suggest it wasn't sustainable.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:10PM (#16395632)
So they would have preferred it, possibly come to a different conclusion, if Uber would have been likely to be established as a perpetual monopoly?
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:29PM (#16395801)
It's not a normative argument.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:47PM (#16396030)
So they did not base any decision on the observation?
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:10PM (#16396304)
I don't understand what you are asking.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:20PM (#16396438)
My interpretation of your comments is that the state of North Carolina used as an argument against deregulating its taxi market to an extent that would allow Uber to operate in the state that Uber might not survive the ensuing competition.

If so, that is indeed then a normative observation, and it's also a pretty silly argument. Thus, my incredulity that is actually the case. I'd be interested in knowing what, then, their argument actually was.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:31PM (#16396558)
NC stands for "Naked Capitalism," the Web site on which the linked article appears.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:41PM (#16396661)
face-palm

Okie dokie, forget what I said. Sorry.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by clairity on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:02PM (#16396213)
> but the general idea isn't "price below what is sustainable by taking in massive amounts of funding until all of your competitors are sunk and then increase prices."

so there shouldn't be any startups then?

because every startup is unsustainable at the beginning. every startup wants to beat its competition and emerge as the sole winner. every startup wants to raise prices and make more money.

capitalism is an economic system where individuals own (and deploy) the means of production, not the state. capitalism employs competition to ensure those means of production are put to productive uses for the whole economy, not just the individual. profits (or more directly, the accumulation of wealth) are non-productive until redeployed.

that's exactly the way capitalism is designed to work.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by EpicEng on Saturday February 17, 2018 @11:48AM (#16401439)
>because every startup is unsustainable at the beginning. every startup wants to beat its competition and emerge as the sole winner. every startup wants to raise prices and make more money.

With the idea that they will eventually become sustainable. And let's not pretend that manu (most?) startups are a massive cash sink-hole run by people who don't really know what they're doing. Regardless, if your startup's plan is to start cheap, grow their user base until they have a network effect, and then raise their prices significantly _and_ the product they offer can be easily replicated... then yes, that startup should probably not exist.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:37PM (#16394641)
That's not really how it's "supposed to" work. It's called predatory pricing and the most ardent free-market defenders claim it doesn't exist because it's economically irrational (check out the contentious discussion and Frankenstein-like text of the Wikipedia entry on the topic).
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by sol_remmy on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:00PM (#16394869)
"predatory pricing"

So they're offering prices below cost and that is considered "predatory"? Last time I checked low prices are good for consumers

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:30PM (#16395211)
It's predatory because it is below cost and is just intended to preserve a monopoly on a market. The goal is to eliminate all competitors, then charge a price that a competitive market couldn't sustain. The harder it is for new competitors to enter your market the better it works.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by jfrankamp on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:18PM (#16395079)
In the long run, higher prices for consumers. After the predatory prices have driven out competition.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:04PM (#16394920)
> most ardent free-market defenders claim it doesn't exist

Yes, and the people on the other side of that debate are perfectly reasonable, dispassionate truth-seekers.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:33PM (#16395230)
Do you feel I've unfairly presented someone's position? I don't agree with it but I think I have presented their case reasonably. Unless your objection was to my claim that they are "ardent defenders of the free market," but I think that is a reasonable characterization of the Adam Smith tie types.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:51PM (#16395465)
You've misrepresented the conflict as being one-sided, when it's not. There's a real difference of opinion and analysis, and plenty of "ardency" on both sides.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:59PM (#16395537)
On one side you have people who believe that predatory pricing is an issue and likely also that government regulation is needed to prevent it. On another you have people who believe that markets are so efficient that predatory pricing cannot happen. What do you think I'm missing here? Can you be any more specific than just vaguely saying I'm missing some nuance?
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:03PM (#16395576)
You only said half of that. That was what you were missing.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:30PM (#16395821)
I figured the reader could easily infer that there was a different group of people who did believe in predatory pricing.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:49PM (#16396046)
Yes, and that this group wasn't ardent.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:54PM (#16396111)
I meant to contrast "ardent free market defenders," i.e., people in the libertarian end of the spectrum, with those concerned about predatory pricing, many of whom would not consider themselves opponents of the free market. "Ardent" is not, in the first place, pejorative.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:14PM (#16396369)
It is (mildy, granted) pejorative in the description of a participant in a debate, especially when only one party is it.

Search for the truth is about collecting and reviewing evidence. Being passionate (synonym of ardent) about one side (rather than possibly the inquiry itself) is a bad quality.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:33PM (#16396584)
I originally wrote "extreme" but thought someone might take offense at the use of such a loaded term. Sometimes there's no winning, I guess.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by mseebach on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:57PM (#16396832)
It's not about offence. I'm not offended. I'm challenging your misrepresentation of a debate.

The idea that predatory pricing not only exists, but is prevalent, is the main plank of the argument that competition doesn't work and wont generally sort out bad behaviour in the market, so lots of people who ideologically need that to be true cling very dearly to that idea. On the other side of the debate are a lot of people with an incomplete appreciation of the complexity of what markets can and can't sort out, especially the pretty non-ideal ones we're stuck with in a world where among other things governments and regulations play, for better or for worse, a non-trivial role.

Lost in this mess is any nuanced discussion of when predatory pricing might and especially might not occur.

And now we're getting to the point. A reasonably free market for taxis (and a such can well include requirements for insurance, background checks and rigorous book keeping) will not allow predatory pricing to occur, and this is trivially easy to show. This does not mean that predatory pricing doesn't or can't exist, just that it certainly can't on a market with these characteristics.

Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by emodendroket on Friday February 16, 2018 @07:15PM (#16397891)
Well, I don't think you disagree that much with the folks at this site. Their idea is that Uber may be able to drive competitors out of business with predatory pricing, but they won't be able to keep more competitors from coming back as soon as they raise prices.
Re:Can Uber Ever Deliver? Even After 4Q Cost Cuts, Uber Lost... by albertgoeswoof on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:51PM (#16394784)
So if you invest when a company is at the end of that temporary window, you’re going to lose money? Remind me of the difference between that an MLM scheme again?