News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:00PM (#1639167)
Respectfully, Colin, but you price Tarsnap horribly. You run it like a public utility (a very complicated public utility) instead of a business.

You think this is a good thing, but it's not. Instead of setting a simple price based on what Tarsnap is worth to people --- a task that requires figuring out what Tarsnap is worth to different people and selecting the segment of the market that(a) you want to serve and (b) is sufficiently lucrative --- you have a fundamentally cost-based micro-metering structure that almost certainly radically undercharges most of your users.

You may think you're doing your users a favor by letting them off easy. But you're not. If Tarsnap is worth $11/mo to most of your users (hint: it is) and you charge $10/mo, you're generating value for them. But instead of doing that, you charge them almost nothing, and as a result are much more limited in what you can do for them. Last I checked, you were consulting instead of full-timing Tarsnap.

If you charged more, you could afford to:

* Radically overhaul your website and educate users about what secure backup actually means

* Commission a better user interface for people who you'd like to offer secure backup to but can't because they're not going to use a Unix command-line tool

* Implement more and better features on the backend of your system for tracking data, scheduling backups, backing up different kinds of data, and whatnot

This is all apart from the obvious point that your micro-metered pricing scheme is a Mensa test that almost makes fun of people's attempts to figure out what your service costs. Yes, the fact that it costs much too little means the joke is on you, but that doesn't really take the sting out of it for your prospective customers.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by _delirium on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:28PM (#1639460)
I'm quite likely in the minority, but I strongly gravitate to services that 1) use a cost-based micro-pricing scheme; and 2) that I trust to not mark-up unreasonably much. Generally I want to offload the "how much should this kind of thing cost?" calculation to someone else who I can trust to calculate it accurately, add on a reasonable profit margin, and charge me that amount. I definitely avoid companies that I feel are instead trying to figure out how much they can get me to pay, and then pricing it at that.

One example, which I use for hosting, is nearlyfreespeech.net. Amazon's and Google's cloud services have a similar utility-pricing model, though I'm not sure how much I personally trust them to price in line with costs, especially whether they're going to pass on future cost decreases. Prgmr.com is a flat fee rather than a combination of micro-prices, but it has a little of the same vibe of, "I calculated how much it should cost to operate these servers, divided by the number of VPSs, added on a reasonable profit margin, and that's what I'm charging", which is one reason I went with them.

It's not even necessarily the overall price that worries me so much as liking the general warm-and-fuzzy feeling that I'm not getting a hugely marked up service. Same as when shopping for, say, a mechanic: I feel most comfortable with a mechanic I can trust to charge me what the repair costs, plus a reasonable profit, not one who's trying to size me up to figure out how much the repair is "worth to me".

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by cperciva on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:07PM (#1639192)
As always, Thomas, I value your feedback even though I'm not going to take your advice. :-)

Just to set the record straight on one point, though:

Last I checked, you were consulting instead of full-timing Tarsnap.

Yes, I do consulting, but it's a very small fraction of my time. And honestly, I think what I learn from the consulting is worth far more than the money I get.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:11PM (#1639204)
I'm glad you're consulting. I hope you consult a lot more, so you'll come around to my way of thinking on the futility of advising generalist devs on writing crypto primitives. So look at it this way: if you'd stop running Tarsnap like a subsidized metered utility, you could hire someone to compensate for your weak spots.

It is, as Patrick will testify after many an evening conversation in Chicago, "all love" with you & me & these critiques. Your project should be epic by now, and it's driving me a little crazy.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by StavrosK on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:08PM (#1639391)
Since you seem to know a lot about pricing, could you give me a few pointers on what one would charge for something like http://historio.us/? Apparently you guys feel that $15 isn't a lot of money, but where I live it's not disposable income...
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:15PM (#1639411)
All I can tell you is:

* you have to find out what the value your service generates is to different groups of customers (an MBA would call them "segments").

* you have to figure out the cost of acquiring and maintaining customers in each segment.

* you price based on the value (if it creates $10/mo apparent value, that's the number with a gravitational pull).

* bust out cleverness to figure out ways to capture money from high-value low-volume segments without scaring away low-value high-volume segments.

I'm close enough to Colin's target market to know that "just stick the server's filesystem in tarsnap and don't even bother taking an inventory of what's on the machine" is worth multiples of S3+80% just in recovered admin productivity.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by StavrosK on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:17PM (#1639416)
Ah, thank you.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by maxawaytoolong on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:18PM (#1639419)
I would pay $2.99 for the iPhone reader and $0 for the website because that's what Instapaper charges and this seems about the same.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by StavrosK on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:27PM (#1639453)
Hmm, I think we need to change the copy. Everyone says it's the same as instapaper, even though there's no overlap... Thanks for your input!
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by listic on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:20PM (#1639883)
Can you make it a browser add-on instead of bookmarklet? I don't know about the others, but I find the bookmarks toolbar clumsy and unnecessary and never turn it on. But I have at least a dozen add-ons installed.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by StavrosK on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:42PM (#1639967)
Yes, we already have a chrome extension and a firefox extension is in the works. Unfortunately, only opera allows you to place bookmarklets anywhere in the UI. I don't like the toolbar very much either, but you can also add it to your bookmarks menu, it's just a bookmark.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by jacquesm on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:16PM (#1639223)
I ran the numbers a while ago on using Tarsnap for our business and it's not as cheap as you make it out to be.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:26PM (#1639277)
That only makes his pricing model worse, not better. He's doing $3/user (ie: not enough) and managing to chase off serious users by forcing them to think carefully about the pricing.

Here is a hint, Colin: any time a prospect says he's "run the numbers" on your pricing, you just received a strong signal that you need to simplify pricing. Purchasing decisions should be made in the limbic system.

Think about it: if you charged $5/mo and put an obscenely high cap on storage for the $5/mo account, then by your own math you'd be hugely improving your revenue, and at the same time you'd be charging half of this original poster's pain threshold number --- which is referring not to crazy encrypted backup solutions but to things like to-do lists!

At EnterAct, the ISP I ran tech-ops for, my old boss Mike Cloran came up with what he called the "5/30" pricing scheme, which we used to great effect to grab customers from other ISPs. Other ISPs were either metered (which scared the shit out subscribers) or flat-rate (which chased away light-users). The 5/30 plan was: $5/mo + $1/hour, capped at $30.

This is actually not a great deal and it is not particularly sophisticated (it is... wait for it... a capped metered plan). But it simplified the buying decision for people, addressed their perceived risks, and made EnterAct seem even more flexible than it already was.

Pricing is the hardest part of product marketing. There's a reason why established companies don't let just anyone do it. Your pricing scheme punts on it.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by cperciva on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:51PM (#1639345)
Think about it: if you charged $5/mo and put an obscenely high cap on storage for the $5/mo account, then by your own math you'd be hugely improving your revenue [...]

... and also hugely increasing my costs. With all due respect, I've talked to a lot more Tarsnap users than you have, Thomas, and I also have the advantage of seeing how much data people upload and how much they delete.

Your suggested pricing model would result in people uploading far more data and never deleting any of it, and would very rapidly move Tarsnap from "profitable" to "bankrupt".

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:00PM (#1639364)
Then lower the cap. Or do what Mozy does, and charge $5/mo + $1/mo/g (they charge 0.50/mo/gig, but with no Tarsnap sauce).

If Mozy can charge 0.50/mo/gig, 0.30/mo/gig is way too cheap.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by jacquesm on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:29PM (#1639921)
I think a big part of the reason underlying why I can't afford it is that it uses amazon for the storage, and that is already quite a fee for large amounts of data even before the tarsnap markup.

The security is of lesser consideration for me, the convenience was the main selling point.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:47PM (#1639985)
Congratulations, Colin. Your pricing model has people thinking about your service in terms of "a markup over Amazon S3". =)
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by cperciva on Saturday August 28, 2010 @01:51AM (#1641294)
I'm sure you think me crazy, but that's what I was aiming for. I want people to be able to say, like _delirium and wwortiz did, "this is clearly a reasonable price because he's using S3 for backing storage and we know how much S3 costs".

A critical part of trust is transparency, and in the long term I think I'll do better by having transparent and obviously reasonable pricing than by obscuring things and trying to maximize my (short-term) profits.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Saturday August 28, 2010 @02:07AM (#1641315)
Exactly what does your cost of storage have to do with the value of the service you provide?
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by cperciva on Saturday August 28, 2010 @02:26AM (#1641339)
It doesn't. But people aren't rational -- they'll reject a good deal (including free money!) if they think the person offering the deal is making out better than they are.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by schindyguy on Saturday August 28, 2010 @04:08AM (#1641453)
I think you guys are just looking at value differently.

I didn't know about either of your companies but by the discussion, its clearly possible for Tarsnap users to derive value from the trust associated with transparency and feeling like their dollar is maximized. tptacek, pricing schemes aren't the only component of the purchase decision or profitability. His users are making a more emotional decision. cperciva should stick to the core of what his users are finding valuable...then get bought out and turn into an evil profit maximizing company

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by wwortiz on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:51PM (#1639996)
Personally I think of it as a value added markup as a good thing.

Using S3 would cost me more per month unless I implemented a similar system to tarsnap.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:55PM (#1640021)
Seeing how Amazon's whole business model is basically to commoditize storage (and cycles and database queries) and drive prices as low as possible, their price per gigabyte seems like a very dangerous star for Colin to hitch his wagon to.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by fluidcruft on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:28PM (#1639288)
You know what? Newsflash to all the brilliant people trying to make a mint by playing S3 middlemen... You're one free-software client from being irrelevant. $10/month is enough to motivate me to hack in my spare time. At $3/month... meh, maybe I'll scratch a different itch.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:38PM (#1639310)
Try to hack up a replacement to tarsnap in your spare time and you are a lot more likely to embarass yourself than to give Colin a run for his money. S3 isn't the underlying value in Tarsnap.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by fluidcruft on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:14PM (#1639405)
Nice try. If tarsnap does anything that duplicity or s3napback doesn't do, I wouldn't know it from the tarsnap website.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:23PM (#1639443)
You are right that Tarsnap's website does a terrible job communicating the value. You're wrong about everything else. But I'm glad Colin is getting the data point here.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by StavrosK on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:04PM (#1639375)
I haven't used Tarsnap, but it looks very similar to duplicity at a cursory glance. Are there many differences?
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:08PM (#1639386)
Yes: Tarsnap is extremely secure, and so it can be used inside companies with sensitive data without wasting time classifying what can and can't be backed up remotely.

It is like the Iron Mountain of backup solutions.

Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by StavrosK on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:16PM (#1639412)
Duplicity GPG-encrypts all data too, though.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by tptacek on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:19PM (#1639424)
For the sake of argument (or, because you trust me on this), let's stipulate that Tarsnap is significantly more secure than duplicity; things can go wrong with duplicity (or create untenable administrative headaches) that don't with Tarsnap.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by cperciva on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:39PM (#1639315)
Tarsnap isn't just an S3 middleman. The Tarsnap client-server API is considerably more powerful (e.g., transactions, amortized S3 PUT costs) and you can't replicate the functionality on the client alone.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by krschultz on Friday August 27, 2010 @05:15PM (#1640302)
$7 a month for how much of your time? $7 for me is less than 10 minutes of time a month and I graduated school in May, it's not like I'm making an outrageous salary. $7 is the difference between going out to Subway for lunch or making a sandwhich in the morning, which is a decision I base every single day solely on how I feel when I wake up in the morning.
Re:Ask HN: What's up with all these services charging $10/$1... by fluidcruft on Friday August 27, 2010 @06:18PM (#1640477)
When you go to subway do you pay for the sandwich or do you subscribe to a $x/month recurring charge that gives you up to y sandwiches/month whether you eat them or not?