Re:Federal Judge Says Embedding a Tweet Can Be Copyright Inf...
by dbuder on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:31PM
(#16389878)
How is tweeting not considered putting it into the public domain, it's open broadcast.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Federal Judge Says Embedding a Tweet Can Be Copyright Inf...
by ruytlm on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:46PM
(#16389937)
Because being on the receiving end of a public broadcast does not give you the right to re-use the content. The content owner, for better or worse, typically retains the exclusive right to use or broadcast the content, regardless of how many times it is broadcast.
Consider older mediums; does broadcasting a TV show put it into the public domain? Or playing a song on the radio?
Re:Federal Judge Says Embedding a Tweet Can Be Copyright Inf...
by mcbits on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:32AM
(#16390811)
> Consider older mediums; does broadcasting a TV show put it into the public domain? Or playing a song on the radio?
In a sense, it does, yeah. It's just that copyright injects a century or so of lag time before members of the public domain are allowed to exercise their rights.
Re:Federal Judge Says Embedding a Tweet Can Be Copyright Inf...
by alphaalpha101 on Friday February 16, 2018 @12:51AM
(#16390214)
>Consider older mediums; does broadcasting a TV show put it into the public domain? Or playing a song on the radio?
It certainly should do.
Re:Federal Judge Says Embedding a Tweet Can Be Copyright Inf...
by djsumdog on Friday February 16, 2018 @12:07AM
(#16390006)
Well the tweet is under whatever terms Twitter imposes on you for using their service. But in this particular case, someone tweets a photo some other origination copyrighted.
I mean, technically taking a photo of a movie poster and tweeting it is infringement, but most movie companies have better things to do than go after you for it, especially if it's not disparaging and may promote the movie.
Re:Federal Judge Says Embedding a Tweet Can Be Copyright Inf...
by delecti on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:44PM
(#16389925)
Twitter isn't quite an open broadcast, and even if it were it wouldn't necessarily mean it was entered into the public domain. A recording of a musician's public performance of their song is still under copyright; MLK's "I Have a Dream" speech is under copyright; literal broadcasts (TV/Radio) are still under copyright.