News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Email is your electronic memory by nextos on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @06:56PM (#16380758)
Yes, this might become an embrace, extend, extinguish like scenario, which is scary.

Google did the same thing with XMPP and Google Talk. They adopted an open standard when it was cool for them. When they gained mass adoption, they switched to Hangouts and the whole Allo mess. And before that they crippled XMPP federation.

While I don't like regulations too much, it might be desirable to penalize these behaviors as they are monopolistic.

Re:Email is your electronic memory by cromwellian on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @07:39PM (#16380969)
Google Talk never gained mass adoption. Google was punished by their competitors by adopting open standards, like XMPP and OpenID, when some competitors implemented "one way" interoperabilility to siphon off users.

I favor federated open standards, but let's not rewrite history. Google Talk was never mass adopted or a market leader, MSN, Yahoo Messenger, AOL Messenger always had way more market share.

I mean, good lord, you're calling for regulations to penalize Google over failed messaging products, why don't you call on regulations to force Apple and Facebook who own the world's most popular messaging platforms, to open up their protocols to federation?

Re:Email is your electronic memory by toomuchtodo on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @08:59PM (#16381374)
If you want to propose legislation to require Apple and Facebook to allow interoperability, I will get it in front of federal legislators.
Re:Email is your electronic memory by Promarged on Thursday February 15, 2018 @06:17AM (#16383185)
I've been pondering this for a while. The standard thinking is if everyone federated (e.g. XMPP in Facebook, Gmail) it would be good. But look at it from another perspective. Then your main account, your identity would be permanently tied to one provider (Facebook, Google) as your JID would end with @facebook.com.

The only true solution is to use your own domain and then, if possible, delegate to hosted server. If the provider does something that you don't like you just change provider or host your own. And one's @gmail.com address will always be hosted by Google.

Re:Email is your electronic memory by cornholio on Thursday February 15, 2018 @05:48AM (#16383092)
how exactly does one siphon users by implementing one-way federation in XMPP?
Re:Email is your electronic memory by cromwellian on Thursday February 15, 2018 @03:22PM (#16387254)
The same way iMessage siphons from SMS. You embrace-and-extend, crafting a proprietary protocol closed service with a bridge to an open one. You gain users by allowing people to inter operate with friends outside your proprietary service: normally a "cost" and impediment to your users, all the while creating incentives to onboard their friends. Once they're onboarded, they become locked in, and gradually you can reduce interoperability with the federation.
Re:Email is your electronic memory by cornholio on Thursday February 15, 2018 @04:09PM (#16387643)
Well, I would say that applies to open protocols themselves, like SMS and XMPP - in fact Google did it also. But when two service providers interoperate and build more features to entice users to move to their platform, I would call it fair competition not siphoning; there is no "one way" aspect, you either federate or not.

What I want to say is that killing XMPP federation was a deliberate stab against a competitive market, not some reasonable defense against being taken advantage of, it's exactly the final "reduce interoperability" step you talk about. Unless competition regulators disagree, it's fair game for Google, but the consumers certainly stand to lose.