News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The story of round rectangles by philwelch on Thursday August 26, 2010 @10:06PM (#1637812)
Showing how clever the oval algorithm was gives us the right emotional setup to the conflict--Atkinson is justly proud of his own cleverness until Jobs, almost dismissively, demands even more from him. The central conflict of the story isn't between Atkinson and the problem, it's between Atkinson and Jobs, and the story holds itself to the emotionally salient facts about how that conflict is resolved--the rounded rectangles work and Atkinson is again very proud and happy.

Well, either that or Hertzfeld never got around to learning how roundrects were implemented.

I get your complaint, because that's not the conflict you wanted the story to center around, but given the conflict it does center around, I don't think it's that poorly composed.

Re:The story of round rectangles by Semiapies on Friday August 27, 2010 @11:59AM (#1639161)
Well, I'd rather the story center more firmly around the Atkinson/Jobs conflict or the whole sweep of Atkinson going from clever hack to being convinced about the rounded rectangles to figuring them out as well. I don't need to know the math to appreciate the trickiness of making quick ovals on Lisa hardware, but if we're going into that, I want to know how he worked out the roundrects as well.