It's the difference between easier to debug: "you asked me to read a value here, but your assumptions about the encoding don't match reality" exception and the hard to debug: "I did a lot of processing; you thought this thing is a valid text, but it isn't; have fun tracking down how it got here in the first place" exception.
Proposed "string like" Object: __IF__ you want to turn on debugging, sure, force it to validate assumptions at runtime/compile time. Otherwise call verify() when you're willing to handle that being some result indicating "we have a problem".
Maybe the verify() call returns the byte-access-offset of the first non-conforming sequence.
I think we've got a fundamental disagreement here. I don't believe they're similar at all. They just happened to get confused a lot in the past when it didn't matter that much.
That would be a terrible thing for people who work with strings as strings, and would essentially tell such people -- who make up a lot of Python's user base! -- "go use something else, this language is only for sysadmins to write Unix utilities now".
If you require an eternally frozen implementation of Python 2's behavior in order to get your work done, you can download the source and keep it around as long as you like. Nobody else has an obligation to support you or hold back the rest of the world in order to suit your use case in your preferred way.