Re:The story of round rectangles
by joblessjunkie on Thursday August 26, 2010 @01:58PM
(#1636661)
I especially don't buy the idea that Bill Atkinson, after demonstrating fast ellipses, would then claim that rounded rects would be "really hard." Indeed, the enhancement would be trivial.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think that Atkinson probably thought that roundrects would be a useless addition that would bloat the library. (Remember, the entire Mac OS and applications needed to fit in 128K!)
It's easier to dismiss something as "entirely too hard" than to get into an argument about whether it's worth implementing.
Re:The story of round rectangles
by toddheasley on Thursday August 26, 2010 @07:41PM
(#1637532)
A lot of the best inventions seem obvious after the first person comes up with them. Especially when it comes to code.
I disagree. I think round rects have more edge cases than ovals (such as a 10 pixels high rectangle with corner radii of 8 pixels)
It could also be that he thought it would be too hard because he knew he only had 42 bytes of ROM space to play with.
Re:The story of round rectangles
by DLWormwood on Thursday August 26, 2010 @09:03PM
(#1637705)
I found this in the comments of the posted article’s website:
It's not that doing rounded rects would be hard, but that doing them really fast would be hard.
Re:The story of round rectangles
by angrycoder on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:50PM
(#1639343)
Everything is trivial in hindsight.