News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why There Aren't More Googles by nostrademons on Monday April 14, 2008 @08:40PM (#163652)
"Why are VCs so conservative? ..."

I just read a fascinating book - Gut Feelings by Gerd Gigerenzer. It's by the guy who did most of the research that Malcolm Gladwell's Blink is based upon. The central thesis was that people have evolved heuristics for decision making that let them quickly make snap decisions more effectively than gathering full information, but a couple chapters were on an interesting corollary: in the absence of hard data on their performance, most people's decision-making heuristic falls back to "Will I be blamed for this decision?"

He provided a bunch of examples from different professions. For example, doctors' decisions often aren't based on solid evidence-based medicine (which is often contradictory), but rather on "Will I be sued if I do or don't perform this treatment?" If you want the doctor's actual opinion, you should ask "If it were your own mother, what would you recommend?" instead of "What would you recommend I do?" - the former shifts the doctor's perspective so that they're thinking "How can I provide the best care?" rather than "Will this person sue me?" A study of UK magistrates found that 92% of their bail decisions could be predicted by the following heuristic: "Did any of the prosecution, police, or previous court recommend bail?" If not, and the defendant commits a crime, it falls into the category of unforeseeable events and the magistrate can't be blamed for it.

A similar effect may be at work with VCs. It's usually impossible to know, even with hindsight, what the opportunity cost of a lost deal was. If a VC turns down the next Google, chances are nothing happens and the company just fizzles. If a VC invests and it goes bust, however, everyone knows. So it pays for the VC to invest like everyone else does: then they can blame any failure on "Well, this was completely unforeseeable: everyone else was sure they'd be a success too." It's the combination of risk aversion, self-interest, and lack of feedback that drives this. If VCs actually had solid conceptual frameworks and good data for evaluating possible opportunities, they could rely on that rather than on their peers' evaluations. (Maybe this explains Sequoia...)

Re:Why There Aren't More Googles by Alex3917 on Tuesday April 15, 2008 @12:49AM (#163824)
"If VCs actually had solid conceptual frameworks and good data for evaluating possible opportunities, they could rely on that rather than on their peers' evaluations."

This is basically the argument for thesis driven investing. If you Google the term there is some good stuff, especially the posts by Bill Burnham and Fred Wilson.

Re:Why There Aren't More Googles by Xichekolas on Tuesday April 15, 2008 @01:18PM (#164307)
Ironic that you mention Fred Wilson, since he (or his doppelganger) apparently read drafts of PG's essay (and hence presumably influenced it somewhat).