News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'I really want to find it before I die': why are we so fa... by jacquesm on Monday February 12, 2018 @02:36PM (#16361332)
Is there a point in citing a paper that readers can not find for themselves?
Re:'I really want to find it before I die': why are we so fa... by btrettel on Monday February 12, 2018 @03:59PM (#16362069)
This is a fair point. Here's my thinking: Just because a paper is hard to find does not mean that it doesn't have valuable data or ideas. To give an example, I spent a lot of time tracking down Russian papers in my field because I found their theory to be better developed in some areas than the west's. Should I not cite these papers because most people won't be able to find them? I don't think so. What they say is unique. There is no alternative.

Instead, I translated the most important papers into English. In a conference paper I'm writing right now I cite quite a few of these papers and I've tried to be extremely specific in their citations, going so far as to include OCLC numbers that I used for interlibrary loan. (Librarians will know what to do with this information.)

What's easily found today may not be so easily found in the future. Today, I find that many researchers can't find a paper that's not available online but is available in any decent academic library.

It's also possible that a hard to find paper is cited wrong or cited ambiguously, and having the correct, unambiguous citation is all one needs to find the paper.

To address papers which are practically impossible to track down, as gms7777 suggested, at least people can contact the author of the paper citing the hard to find paper in this case. (For the Hinze paper, as I recall Shell had a NDA as a condition of downloading the paper from their system, so I can't share that one.)

Re:'I really want to find it before I die': why are we so fa... by gms7777 on Monday February 12, 2018 @03:20PM (#16361686)
Purely from principles, one might consider it important to credit people for the ideas that they contributed.

From a practical sense, it gives readers a way to find it for themselves -- contact the author that cited it.

Re:'I really want to find it before I die': why are we so fa... by jacquesm on Monday February 12, 2018 @04:03PM (#16362117)
> Purely from principles, one might consider it important to credit people for the ideas that they contributed.

That makes good sense.

> From a practical sense, it gives readers a way to find it for themselves -- contact the author that cited it.

Right, but in the case of a paper this old the author is most likely dead or extremely hard to reach. Maybe a standard part of any paper citing other papers should be a reference to an archived copy of the papers cited?