Re:Sweden tried to drop Assange extradition in 2013
by untog on Monday February 12, 2018 @10:58AM
(#16359446)
> It is still alleged.
Of course it is, Assange never came in for questioning! That's the reason people are arrested: so that they can be charged. Since he evaded arrest, he hasn't been charged. It's absurdly circular logic to suggest that this implies innocence.
Re:Sweden tried to drop Assange extradition in 2013
by crdoconnor on Monday February 12, 2018 @11:07AM
(#16359518)
I am not implying here that he is innocent - though I think he probably is. I'm just stating that the crime was and still is alleged. The fact that the Swedish prosecutors never took up his invitation to question him in the embassy doesn't change that.
You did a little more than imply he was guilty. You directly called him guilty when you used the phrase "a crime was committed".
You are now contradicting yourself by agreeing that the crime was alleged.
Re:Sweden tried to drop Assange extradition in 2013
by untog on Monday February 12, 2018 @11:14AM
(#16359566)
Good grief, if that was your original point you really could have phrased it better, it wasn't clear at all. That said, mea cupla: you're right that my own phrasing could have been better, I've amended it.
(it certainly wasn't directly calling him guilty in any case - people are arrested "in connection" to crimes all the time without being accused of being the perpetrator of that crime)
Re:Sweden tried to drop Assange extradition in 2013
by crdoconnor on Monday February 12, 2018 @12:42PM
(#16360305)
>people are arrested "in connection" to crimes all the time
Where the crime is known while the criminal is not this is true.
No, I think he was implying that until he's been successfully using the phrase "a crime that was committed" is premature. It is still alleged.
If you want to know who did say "in light of Assange's political activity this crime is likely not credible" well... that would inconveniently be GCHQ:
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2013/may/20/julian-assange...
>That doesn't stand up to any logical scrutiny
Straw men usually don't.