> > But as for Slack, you DO have to be a team player.
That was the point of my original comment: in one of these organizations, the fact that I struggle to work because I have noise coming from Slack that I'm expected to respond to is NOT my lack of discipline. The person I was responding to just took a fashionable meme on HN which was originally meant for Facebook and mindlessly applied it to Slack. Not applicable.
It's the external expectation to respond that I interpreted as "being a team player as measured by always being on Slack".
Being a team player, broadly defined, isn't incompatible with muting Slack or otherwise managing the noise, and that then comes back to the "discipline" idea. If a person don't mute Slack because they "like" the distractions, then they have a discipline problem, if the organisation doesn't let them mute Slack because a "team player" always responds in three seconds or less, they the organisation has a discipline problem.
I don't know what kind of place you work at, but being a team player isn't measured by always being on Slack.