All your non-defunct fundees are still "building", but that's not the same as accepting groups you know are going to take two years and a lot more funding right at the outset.
As for caring about the founders/investing in people instead of ideas, that doesn't hold up for several reasons: 1) If you really end up changing the idea so often anyway, as often claimed, the idea proposed wouldn't be grounds for rejection if the founders were otherwise good; 2) Many founders don't have track records, thus you have nothing to judge them on; 3) Some applicants do have track records, but you reject them without reviewing the stuff they've done due to lack of time or other reasons.
And by building, I meant two years to launch. There's a startup we funded two years ago that's launching in late spring or early summer.
It's kind of amusing the rejectees not only got a form letter, but a recycled one, which wasn't even accurate!
The first batch was in the summer of 2005.
I wonder why time seems to accelerate as we age. Is it because we are more busy, and hence spend less time being bored? Or is it somehow related to the fact that any given year's memories are an ever shrinking percentage of my overall memory store? If I were rich I would study people's perception of time, because it seems so non-linear.
This goes for YC as well. Surely there are some technically innovative applicants that don't fit the mould of web sites to make quizzes or 10-second cartoons or other such dubious acceptees.
Google itself would have been rejected on at least a couple of grounds: project being too big to make much progress in 3 months (crawling the entire web!), and needing too much money ($15k ought to be enough for anybody!). IIRC they got not only the $100k from Bechtolsheim but also a similar amount from Cheriton.
> And yet it's the bold ideas that generate the biggest returns.
Yet YC sticks with smaller ideas...
> It's remarkable how wedded they are to their standard m.o.
This also seems to apply to YC. Small idea, $15k, 3 months, move your ass to Boston (then move again to SV, where you should have been in the first place), standard terms, no negotiation of the offer if YC accepts you.