Re:A Democrat is running for president on a platform of Univ...
by saas_co_de on Sunday February 11, 2018 @08:00PM
(#16355780)
This is what Earned Income Credit does. It seems to work pretty well.
Re:A Democrat is running for president on a platform of Univ...
by gremlinsinc on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:47PM
(#16355721)
how's that fair if you have person a working in a callcenter for slightly better pay than person b working at McDonalds.
Person A makes 20k, person B makes 10k. Both work pretty shitty jobs -- I wouldn't want either.. Both work the same hours. No more jobs exist for Person A's job, so Person B couldn't rise up to their level if they wanted to.
GBI works because everybody gets it -- so nobody feels like they're getting special treatment, nobody feels like they're on welfare (which causes a mental stigma to begin with) and the goal is simply to cover average rents and maybe some food. Everyone should have food and a roof.
Your plan also doesn't account for what happens when all the jobs for both A and B close down because of automation which is the whole point for why we're discussing GBI more and more anyways.
Re:A Democrat is running for president on a platform of Univ...
by tylerhou on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:50PM
(#16355734)
I'm pretty sure the person you replied to was being satirical.
Re:A Democrat is running for president on a platform of Univ...
by ryanwaggoner on Sunday February 11, 2018 @08:32PM
(#16355905)
Iām not sure why: a NIT has some advantages relative to UBI.
Re:A Democrat is running for president on a platform of Univ...
by slg on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:44PM
(#16355708)
This doesn't address the coming problem of automation in which unemployment numbers are likely to rise. It is also ends up basically being a regressive tax as those who make the least receive the least benefit while those who are already living comfortably receive the full benefit.
Re:A Democrat is running for president on a platform of Univ...
by MaysonL on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:48PM
(#16355725)
See: Earned Income Tax Credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit
Imagine: On your first $24,000 / Year, you are taxed at -50%. This means, if you make $12,000, you get paid an additional $6,000. If you make $24,000, you get paid an additional $12,000. This is an additional reward for working! We want to incentivize working!