Re:Apple's attention to detail
by ZeroGravitas on Thursday August 26, 2010 @05:04AM
(#1635446)
Hold on a minute, are you slating Dell for not patenting something that is indeed trivial, or for not using your idea in their products? Because the former should be applauded.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple's attention to detail
by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday August 26, 2010 @06:27AM
(#1635547)
I think the point isn't that they didn't think it should be patented, more that they really weren't interested in that level of detail generally.
It is trivial but lots of trivial things put together can make for the improved user experience that distinguishes products you can charge top dollar for from the sort of mass market machines Dell turn out.
At the time the bonuses were being handed out, engineers were running pretty much whatever they could think of up the flagpole. Nobody was concerned with the ethics of the situation. (In my defense I pitched only four disclosures at them, out of which only one was accepted for filing.)
Today, if you have a problem with the USPTO's policy of rubber-stamping trivial, obvious, and abstract patents (and I most certainly do), the proper targets for venting are your Congressmen. It's safe to say they don't read Hacker News (hint, hint).