News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaked CIA Red Cell memo on USA 'exporting terrorim' by tptacek on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:58PM (#1633935)
I'm possibly the person on HN who is most vocal about their (current) failings, and even I don't think they're just making things up. I do think, however, that it was a calamitous decision for them to start editorializing. It wasn't a small mistake; it's been devastating to their credibility.

Even in a case like this, the subtexts are all wrong. Why is Wikileaks summarizing anything about this release? Why are they playing it up anywhere? Anyone can read it and see that it's not newsworthy (the issue of reciprocity in extradition isn't just years old, it's decades old!). It's not that any of their sources are false; it's instead the issue that who knows what they're not publishing? Surely, nothing that hurts their narrative!

Re:Leaked CIA Red Cell memo on USA 'exporting terrorim' by InclinedPlane on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:12PM (#1633986)
Sure, I don't believe they're making things up either, yet. But my point is, how do we know? How can we tell?

Their editorializing makes them much more vulnerable to being gamed by people who are willing to make things up (even CBS had this problem). Again, I'm wondering what the value-add of wikileaks is. The access? That seems very outmoded in today's hyper-connected age.