Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre...
by aidenn0 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:48PM
(#1633741)
This is very different from Paschal's wager.
Paschal's wager presents a false dichotomy: either you believe in no god, or you believe in the christian God.
There are a plethora of religions to choose from, and it is also possible that there is a very strange god who puts all athiests in heaven and all believers in hell. Therefore Paschal's wager breaks down.
However, we have a true binary split here when talking about free will.
If there is no free will then from a pragmatic point of view all philosophy is pointless, since it can't effect your decisions.
Paschal's wager presents a false dichotomy: either you believe in no god, or you believe in the christian God.
There are a plethora of religions to choose from, and it is also possible that there is a very strange god who puts all athiests in heaven and all believers in hell. Therefore Paschal's wager breaks down.
However, we have a true binary split here when talking about free will.
If there is no free will then from a pragmatic point of view all philosophy is pointless, since it can't effect your decisions.