Fittingly, I first learned of this concept on Twitter.
It's possible the current state of "bad" affairs is a natural consequence of the democratizing power of the internet itself. Reduced friction means anyone can participate; more participants means lower quality of discussion.
Just a theory as I try to synthesize West's ideas.
Zakaria has some similar arguments:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Future_of_Freedom
This is then applied to America to argue that the increased democratization of American society and culture is what has caused the perceived failures of the government and governing elites.
We have a tendency to see size and democracy as obvious goods, but there are certainly some limits there. It's funny how around the time Digg got going, all the talk was about the "wisdom of the crowds". Not sure anyone wants to make that argument today after 15 years of social media.
Which is the real problem.
Usenet was better because it was before the Internet was interesting to the general population. Twitter sucks for the same reason YouTube comments and /r/all suck - regular people.
There clearly are some problems with the Internet, but nobody is forcing me to use Facebook or Twitter.
But there are some things I emphatically do not miss about the late '90s: Slow modems; even with ISDN, the Internet was painfully slow. Also, no flat rates - in Germany, the phone companies charged for dial-up connections by the minute. No mobile Internet. No Wikipedia. No YouTube. 10 MiB-sized mailboxes. TFT displays cost more than the entire PC I was using at the time (with a crappy CRT display). PCs with less RAM than todays HDDs have in cache. Windows 95 and 98. I could go on and on.
About the only thing I miss more and more often is that I was twenty years younger.
This fact has nothing to do with Trump.
https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/96127083356920217...
I figured the tens of thousands of tweets of people saying hateful things to each other was evidence enough. That thread will do, too.
I was just pointing out Trump said nothing controversial in the aforementioned tweet.
That tweet gave 32k people a chance to voice their opinion on the topic. You may not want to hear it but I bet they appreciated the platform that gave them a voice.
I'm really glad we live in a society that gives people more tools than a voting booth to express themselves.
When in human history have public spheres like Twitter existed? The public sphere up until about 50 years ago for most people was strictly local. You could not broadcast dumb narcissistic ignorance for free to millions of people. It wasn't possible.
Twitter is not good at what it does. It does not elevate public discourse. It's the equivalent of all the newsteams beating the hell out of each other at the end of Anchorman 2.
If you're bullish about Twitter, maybe we should be bearish about our chances as societies and as a species, because Twitter is full of examples of some or our worst behaviors. It's no surprise Trump loves it.
Just as an example, check out this tweet and its thread:
https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/96125316896862208...
It's 32,000 tweets of people shouting at each other.