News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by amichail on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:38AM (#1632918)
There is no scientific evidence for free will. So why believe in it?
Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by petercooper on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:17AM (#1633050)
There's no scientific evidence for the number 7 or the letter "x". They're tokens and constructs relating to man-made abstractions. I put the concept of "free will" into this bucket, also.
Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:43AM (#1632936)
what defines free will, and what scientific evidence would sufficiently prove your definition of free will?
Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by amichail on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:47AM (#1632944)
One can ask something similar about proving the existence of God.

Why should you not believe in God on faith but believe in free will on faith?

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:57AM (#1632980)
sigh. i was really hoping you were trying to take this in another direction.

free will is an objectively observable phenomenon, and the burden of proof is on disproving existence or providing an alternate explanation for the observable. we might not be able to show the mechanisms for why it exists, but we can show that it exists.

god is not objectively observable, and so the burden of proof is on proving existence.

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by Xurinos on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:19AM (#1633057)
> free will is an objectively observable phenomenon

Not true. To observe free will, you must have a really big picture view. You must have enough information at hand to be absolutely confident that the action was not a direct result of all prior experiences of the actor. Until you have that kind of measurement, free will is a matter of faith.

> god is not objectively observable

That is a very human-centric view, and it would behoove any rational thinker to look beyond their own limitations. Again, it is all about having an appropriate instrument to observe Him.

But you may have a point about who owns the burden of proof. (I will not argue either way on who owns it, and whether we should prove or disprove.)

Edit: Sorry, my definition of "objectively" is skewed. Both free will and God can be objectively observed. You just have to have the right instruments, enough information.

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:41AM (#1633141)
> To observe free will, you must have a really big picture view.

why? can you justify this statement?

beyond that, that is not how the scientific method works. you make conclusions on observable data, and if more data becomes accessible, you reconsider conclusions. you can't dismiss conclusions you disagree with by simply saying "you don't have enough data yet to justify my conclusion".

> Again, it is all about having an appropriate instrument to observe Him.

could you elaborate on an appropriate instrument to appropriately observe and identify him in a way that is reproducible for others to also observe objectively?

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by Xurinos on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:32PM (#1633320)
> why? can you justify this statement?

Yes. Based on your next sentence, I think I see where the misunderstanding lies.

You state that the scientific method is about making conclusions on observable data and then discarding them when new data arrives. This is incomplete. Good scientific experiments depend on variables under your control. In layman's terms, you must be in control of everything, know what is going on, and test the specific thing, the one variable you are not controlling. And there are varying degrees of variables involved in the scientific method, along with their complexities.

Now, just in case we already agree and that your statement assumed all that, then I would find fault with the theory that you have sufficient "observable data". That is the entire problem. We already know what you are missing. You need the entire set of experiences that someone has stored in their brain. You need to know the state of the body as well, so that you can identify additional influences (such as a headache, making for hastier decisions based on more recent experiences). You need instruments that can provide you this data, and then you can run your statistics and learn something.

And, of course, you need to have an understanding of the influences of the various experiences and body issues; so you have many studies to run before you get to tackle the issue of free will. Fortunately, we have a LOT of these studies already (and a lot more to do). See psychology, etc.

> could you elaborate on an appropriate instrument to appropriately observe and identify him in a way that is reproducible for others to also observe objectively?

I am in full agreement with your criteria. Maybe one day we will have the technology to do this. Right now, I cannot imagine what the instrument is. I would propose that another god could observe God, or the context of the universe around God could be used in some fashion or produce an instrument to observe God. Maybe in God's metauniverse, there are entities analogous to our rocks, plants, and so forth that could be used to observe His passing.

Taking another approach, this might be akin to gut bacteria trying to prove the existence of Earth. If existence as we know it is an extension of God, how can we identify God? (Trying to avoid the obvious circular argument.)

Anyway, this is all freshman philosophy stuff. Good fodder for coffee talk. Suffice it to say that when we are talking science, we are indeed talking about using tools that "appropriately observe and identify him in a way that is reproducible for others to also observe objectively". Just because we do not have those tools does not invalidate truths about our universe. We did not have a yardstick until the 10th century. We have come a long way since then, and we have a long way to go.

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:18PM (#1633457)
> ... then I would find fault with the theory that you have sufficient "observable data". That is the entire problem.

i agree, and i think then it comes down to each of our own personal opinions, unless you have some hard facts to provide (i surely don't, as you say, this is basically coffee talk for me, here).

sub-question: what do you feel like is the alternative to free will? predestination? do you feel that by disproving free will, it will lead to greater empirical evidence of god or gods (a la "god's plan")? or that proving free will somehow reduces the odds of the existence of god or gods?

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by Xurinos on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:54PM (#1633591)
> what do you feel like is the alternative to free will? predestination?

I would propose that the alternative is manipulation, and the most extreme form of manipulation is predestination. Less extreme forms are environmental manipulation, our bacterial collective, and so forth.

Was it predestined by God or by some initial atomic movement or potential energy? We do not have evidence either way, but it is fair to point out the possibilities. I have my personal belief, which is compatible with both and leaves space for the truth. I see the topic of free will orthogonal to the topic of gods.

We have to be careful here; there are religious beliefs that we humans were granted free will by God. Within that context, if we learn conclusively that free will does not exist, then there was no gift, and it is a blow towards God, although not necessarily disproving God. After all, if we are capable of deceit, isn't it possible that God is also capable of deceit? So what we think we understand from Him might only be what He wants us to see. We also may not be capable of understanding His reasons. In the same vein, HE may simply be a purely creative force with no reasoning other than to make a bunch of stuff and let what sticks stick.

So I think we can erode belief systems -- and our minds are generally frail enough to sway -- but it will be pretty difficult to disprove a god. On the other hand, opportunity may arise where a god can be proven. Perhaps He did reveal himself (several times), and time gave us an easy excuse to forget and deny, to beg for fresh evidence. Today, what could God possibly do that we cannot do that would conclusively prove His existence? And why should He bother?

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:42PM (#1633729)
so, it seems to me that we have different viewpoints. i would say that you have free will until it is completely gone. if you're being manipulated, you have free will but are being externally influenced, and you only have no free will when you are completely predestined.

looks to me like you are the opposite, that you only have free will if you are completely influence-free.

thoughts?

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by Xurinos on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:26PM (#1633852)
Hm. I think we are mostly the same. I would say that you have free will if, after you have removed all possible influences, you are still able to choose. Many things in life reduce your choices, but reduced choices are still choices. We often have choices we ignore or neglect, too.

When I mentioned the manipulation, I meant that it was to be complete manipulation, whatever the source(s). My point was to differentiate it from predestiny, where the manipulator is a fundamental force (God or the movement of the structure of the universe).

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:23PM (#1634025)
you don't think that manipulation on the level of being able to fully remove free will would have to originate from a fundamental force?
Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by Xurinos on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:40PM (#1634078)
I can make my computer output the number 42, and we can argue that there is a force behind me that resulted in that program to output 42 (as well as in Scott Adams's choice of the number and my inevitable reading of his books, etc etc). But it is easier to identify that I manipulated my computer to output 42.

Similarly, our environment may be affected by any number of forces, and we may be entirely pattern-matching, reacting machines who learned how to react from experiences in our environment.

Re:Ask HN: How can you be rational and still believe in fre... by noodle on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @07:47PM (#1634553)
humans are sentient, though. yes, we have DNA that points us in a certain direction, our environment and upbringing point us in a certain direction, but this doesn't necessarily predetermine our outcomes. some people are a product of these things, and others break out of the proverbial mold.