Wæs se grimma gæst Grendel haten, mære mearcstapa, se þe moras heold, fen ond fæsten; fifelcynnes eard wonsæli wer weardode hwile, siþðan him scyppend forscrifen hæfde in Caines cynne.
Many people struggle to read their own language sadly, or comprehend stories with any amount of depth. Old English is probably asking too much of them.
I’m not convinced that this is new though, we’re just far more connected to the LCD than ever before.
Edit: Translation of excerpt:
Grendel this monster grim was called, march-riever mighty, in moorland living, in fen and fastness; fief of the giants the hapless wight a while had kept since the Creator his exile doomed. On kin of Cain was the killing avenged...
That is an extremely simplistic look at literature - you just reduced it to one sentence description of plot alone. That is not how it works and that is not how it ever worked. What makes it hard is the way it is written, presence of either dragon or killing does not make something easier to read. He is right in that most people would not enjoy it.
> And beyond that, there are many books on there that are accessible for anyone who can read.
And many many more that are decisively not accessible. You assume that people will dig for hours through guttenberg to find something fun and accessible, but they wont and probably cant.
There's more in the text than just the plot, but the story alone can be enjoyable without knowing everything else. I'll agree the old translation of an ancient poem is probably still going to be a chore, a better example is something like Dracula.
>And many many more that are decisively not accessible. You assume that people will dig for hours through guttenberg to find something fun and accessible, but they wont and probably cant.
No, I assume that people will find something fun and accessible by the same means they do elsewhere, either through talking to other people or looking at what's popular.
In short, what you’re saying isn’t wrong or unreasonable, but I think it’s fair to say that it reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of what “average” looks like.
And remember what's being discussed here. You can't blame "brainjunk" on people unwilling to pay for content, as they are also ignoring the free content on Project Gutenberg.
Also, if you have hard time to interpret the story, because the sentences are oddly written and unnatural and characters talk the way real people now don't talk, you wont have no fun no matter how many dragons.
> No, I assume that people will find something fun and accessible by the same means they do elsewhere, either through talking to other people or looking at what's popular.
On Guttenberg? That brain junk stuff goes out of their way to reach you. It is completely different model. That is not criticism of Guttenberg, their mission is to preserve and they do it well.
>On Guttenberg? That brain junk stuff goes out of their way to reach you. It is completely different model.
Yeah, this is the point. Project Gutenberg isn't ignored now because you need decades of education to possibly enjoy it, brainjunk is crafted to be addictive.
And the education is necessary to be able to figure out which few books on Guttenberg might be interesting to you. Because overwhelming majority of them is not interesting to you or anyone except few specialists on something.
And majority of that could not possibly replace the kind of reading you do when you relax for 6 minutes between one task and another task at work.
People read in those situations, but that is a different argument altogether.
It is great place for study, good place if you actually are into some historical period and not much of a place if you are contemporary person and just wanna have some fun. No, majority of those most popular books are not fun for most people.
Of course (freedom of choice) one may select the Kardashians (and unfortunately not the Star Trek ones) over poetry. I want them to select what they feel like consuming, and I want me to have the same choice. The problem is with many outlets switching to 'junkfood', the few that may remain become hostage to money-hungry shareholders and thus the game is slowly being lost.