News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:53AM (#1632678)
The pressure does not come from being stigmatized but from the fact that a single person income is not enough to feed a family of four in plenty of places.

Which places?

The fact is, plenty of people survive and overfeed themselves in spite of working less than 27 weeks/year (80% of the poor fall into this category). If a person can't feed their family working full time, they need to move out of Manhattan.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by jacquesm on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:07AM (#1632712)
Because everybody lives in Manhattan? The world is a lot larger than just the US, and even in the US if you've moved out of Manhattan (say to one of those suburbs) and you have a family of four to feed you'll be surprised how much month there is left at the end of your money as a single earner.

Overfeeding is more related to what you eat than the money you spend on it, in fact it is easier to overfeed on cheap food than it is on better grade food.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by kragen on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:44PM (#1633556)
Well, of course it's easier to overfeed on cheap food; you don't run out of money as quickly, and unsurprisingly, the food with the most calories per dollar is also the food that contains the most calories per gram: pure fats and carbohydrates. (Pure alcohol and protein are a bit more expensive, I'll admit, but even pure gluten is pretty cheap.)

Food in the US is much more expensive in the majority of the world. I imagine that in the Netherlands it's even more expensive. Still, home-cooked adequate nutrition in the US costs a great deal less than junk food. McDonald's, Popeye's, and Frito-Lay can't even come close to competing with dried corn, dried beans, dried brown rice, soybean and canola oil, potatoes, squash, onions, collards, carrots, ramen, eggs, multivitamins, oranges, bananas, molasses, oatmeal, and the occasional spinach, lettuce, tomato, and cucumber.

(This was even true when I lived in a poor inner-city black neighborhood in Dayton, where everything in the supermarket cost more, and you couldn't take the carts out into the parking lot. Supermarket prices were a lot cheaper in the rich neighborhoods, and I went to Aldi maybe once a month to stock up on the stuff that was cheap there.)

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by sprout on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:47PM (#1633739)
You have to be smart and fairly industrious to cook. If you can't hold down a job, odds are you can't cook well enough to make it a serious value proposition over pre-packaged and restaurant fare.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by kragen on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:19PM (#1633830)
No, you don't have to be smart to cook. I don't know if you even have to be smart to cook well. I suspect not, because I learned to cook good food pretty quickly; someone who was even dumber than I am might take a little longer, but it still wouldn't be a substantial fraction of a human lifespan.

It does take work, but not a huge amount of work, especially if the aim is to feed your family, not to cook well. Oranges and bananas, you don't even have to cook. A peanut-butter sandwich is two minutes if you already have bread and peanut butter. Cooking brown rice or lentils involves dumping a measuring cup into a pot three or four times and setting a timer. Same thing's true of eggs, oatmeal, polenta, ramen, and grits. Other beans, you have to dump into a pot of water the night before, and you probably ought to sort them so you don't bite a rock, which might take five or ten minutes for a big pot. A big pot of beans and a big pot of rice can satisfy the caloric and protein needs of a family of four for a few days.

And if you dump garlic, onions, butter, soy sauce, salt, pepper, mayonnaise, and hot sauce on any random barely-edible non-sweet crap, you can get it up to the level of McDonald's or Popeye's pretty quick.

There are some cheap foods that require a lot of work. Collards are a pain. Baking your own bread may be cheaper than buying it in a store‚ but it's a lot of work. And about any vegetable you use in a dish is gonna need some slicing. But it doesn't require you to be "industrious" at the level of digging a ditch for eight hours, or working overtime at the bubblebath factory they can't afford to heat.

Now, it's true you aren't born knowing this stuff. You have to learn it, and even if you know it in theory you may not be in the habit of putting it into practice. The soft-drink aisle and the potato chips are pretty tempting. Stopping in at McDonald's on the way home from school is a lot more immediate than stopping at Jewel Osco for a loaf of bread and some peanut butter, even if you evade the peanut butter. And if you've just gotten off your split shift at the call center and you have a couple of kids to feed before you start in on your homework, it's pretty hard to motivate yourself to cook. I'm not trying to minimize the difficulty of being poor in the US.

I'm just saying the problem with food is not that good food is out of reach.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by sprout on Thursday August 26, 2010 @10:48AM (#1636067)
I'm just saying you have to be able to hold down a job well enough that food is not the primary cost driver for your living expenses. You don't have to be at a HN-level of intelligence/industriousness to do that either, but you do have to be reasonably intelligent.

If you can't hold down a decent job, odds are you aren't going to be much use in the kitchen.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by zeteo on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:14AM (#1632726)
Yup. Food has never in history been cheaper as a proportion of total income. Especially if one person stays home to cook all meals, you can feed a family of four with amazing food for $200 a month.

Yes, you need to move out of Manhattan, and give up non-essentials, but a single person on full-time minimum wage can easily feed and house a family of four. Now if that person actually makes an _average_ wage, they can also afford a car, vacations, and college for the kids (they will get good financial aid at that income level).

It's not the finances, it's the societal expectation.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by _pius on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:11AM (#1633028)
"...a single person on full-time minimum wage can easily feed and house a family of four."

With all due respect, you don't know what you're talking about. It's not "societal expectations" that cause lots of gainfully employed people in the United States to be part of the working poor and hungry.

As an example, the minimum wage in DC is $8.25, which yields $1320/month. The actual amount would be even lower after taxes, but let's even forget about that.

About the absolute rock bottom price you'll pay for a room in this city is $600/month and that's assuming you're in a group living situation or a pretty bad neighborhood. Since a family of four will need two rooms to be even reasonably comfortable, maybe you luck out and grab a similarly crappy two-bedroom for $900/month. So now, you pay your rent, somehow keep your utilities hovering around $120/month (good luck with that) and you've got $300/month left.

But wait, now you've got to get to work (and to the grocery store, etc.). Minimum bus fare in this city is $1.50. If you (and just you, not your kids or spouse) make a round trip every day plus, say, three extra trips a month, you will spend about $100.

So now you've got $200 per month left to feed and clothe four people. But what about insurance? Savings? Unforeseen expenses? Doing something nice with your kids every now and again?

At what point does any of this sound easy to you?

If you want to be ignorant, that's your business, but please try not to peddle this BS to others who don't know any better. It's really irresponsible to further the notion that those less fortunate than us are having a difficult time making ends meet because of societal expectations. Ugh.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:22AM (#1633071)
You've got a great theory. And yet, it somehow does not fit the data.

As of 2001 (the most recent data I've seen), more than 2/3 of poor households had at least 2 rooms/person, and only 6% were overcrowded. Just under 3/4 owned a car.

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2004/01/understandi...

In the same year, 80% of the poor neither had nor were looking for a job, so bus fare is irrelevant to most of them. (This number hasn't changed much up to 2008, I haven't seen 2009 data.)

http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2001.pdf

It would seem that even most of the poor do not suffer the problems you describe.

(I'd love more current numbers, anyone have them?)

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by _pius on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:33AM (#1633107)
It fits.

The Heritage Foundation study assailed the Census Bureau's definition of poverty. My point made no comment about that; I was just debunking the idea that a family of four can live "easily" on a single minimum wage income, which is preposterous.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by count on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:08PM (#1633428)
I agree - which is why MOST low-income families of four have a parent who works two minimum wage jobs, which pushes them just above the 'cant make it' threshold (hopefully).
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:06PM (#1633634)
These must be low income families above the poverty line. Below the poverty line, the typical household is supported by 800 hours of work/year (the 8 hour work week).
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by zeteo on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:11PM (#1633649)
" I was just debunking the idea that a family of four can live "easily" on a single minimum wage income, which is preposterous."

An idea that you made up yourself to fight with, and was never supported by anyone else. If karma points were made of straw, you'd be the undisputed champion.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by _pius on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:18PM (#1633666)
It occurs to me that you may not know what a strawman is. It's not attacking a strawman if I'm rebutting a direct quotation from you.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by zeteo on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:27PM (#1633689)
My quotation was "a single person on full-time minimum wage can easily feed and house a family of four". This you confirmed, and it says nothing about other desirable expenses, such as savings, nice clothing and health insurance. The straw man you made out of it is

"I was just debunking the idea that a family of four can live "easily" on a single minimum wage income".

That's BS, my friend.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by _pius on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:29PM (#1633692)
Wow, this has become petty thread crapping on your part and I'm not going to help. I'm done.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by zeteo on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:40PM (#1634898)
Yeah, well - you started it. yummyfajitas and I were having a nice off-topic exchange when you decided to barge in without reading the point properly.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by zeteo on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:09PM (#1633646)
Either you can't read and understand an argument, or you haven't paid attention to the context and the point I was making. I never claimed you're going to live a happy and fulfilling life on minimum wage, that's just a straw man that you chose to put up. Engaging in such "tactics" for a couple of karma points is BS at best and dishonest at worst.

The grand-parent claim for my post is "a single person income is not enough to feed a family of four in plenty of places". (By "feed" most people understand food and housing, not insurance, savings and unforeseen expenses.) My point, which you didn't bother to even read completely before coming here and yelling slogans, was that _even on minimum wage_ one person can pay for housing and food for a family of four (and you have yourself proven this point even for a relatively expensive location such as DC); therefore, _on average wage_, it's possible to do OK with such an arrangement (assuming one person to stay at home and cook). Since financially it works out for the _average_ family, it's social norms that cause the typical situation to be different.

You should really work on your reading comprehension.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by _pius on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:14PM (#1633660)
I never claimed you're going to live a happy and fulfilling life on minimum wage, that's just a straw man that you chose to put up.

Actually, I didn't claim you said that. I simply quoted you saying that "one can easily feed and house a family of four" on a minimum wage income. That's an actual statement you made and I rebutted ... I'm looking at those exact words from you on the screen right now. So where's the strawman? Or the lack of reading comprehension? Or are you actually claiming that you didn't say it?

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by zeteo on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:25PM (#1633682)
Your post, which I quote below, shows that in DC, on minimum wage, you can cover rent, utilities and bus fare for a family of four, and still have about $200 a month left for food. It's exactly my claim, plus I claim that the said $200 are enough to buy ingredients if you cook at home. Is it a great life? No. But it would be OK if you had an _average_ salary for the working person instead. If the person staying at home cooked, did groceries and spent time with the kids, those kids would probably have an even better life than one based on the XBox and microwave dinners.

"As an example, the minimum wage in DC is $8.25, which yields $1320/month. The actual amount would be even lower after taxes, but let's even forget about that.

About the absolute rock bottom price you'll pay for a room in this city is $600/month and that's assuming you're in a group living situation or a pretty bad neighborhood. Since a family of four will need two rooms to be even reasonably comfortable, maybe you luck out and grab a similarly crappy two-bedroom for $900/month. So now, you pay your rent, somehow keep your utilities hovering around $120/month (good luck with that) and you've got $300/month left.

But wait, now you've got to get to work (and to the grocery store, etc.). Minimum bus fare in this city is $1.50. If you (and just you, not your kids or spouse) make a round trip every day plus, say, three extra trips a month, you will spend about $100.

So now you've got $200 per month left to feed and clothe four people. But what about insurance? Savings? Unforeseen expenses? Doing something nice with your kids every now and again?"

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by shadowfox on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:03AM (#1632699)
An alternate choice could be be to have both people work and then stay on in place that you want to?