News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by todayiamme on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @05:06AM (#1632383)
>>>but I'm hoping society will adjust to a point where traditional femininity can peacefully coexist as a respected choice for women on how to live their lives, because I think it can be a suitable, powerful, happy, and meaningful for choice for many women<<<

That's the linchpin you see. The truth is that femininity and masculinity are a continuous spectrum of variation and almost all such statements tend to prescribe something or the other. To tell you the truth I fulfill the stereotype you are proposing in quite a few ways, but most women don't. Just as most males aren't the fist beating cavemen they are made out to be. Why can't we let people just be?

Why do we need to box them into little boxes, so that they conveniently fit into our tiny little realities? Why do we need to make statements like, it's tough to be a man/woman/american/indian/african american/whatever category you can come up with?

It is shocking just how ingrained this is into our consciousness and even though I can articulate it I still can't get it out of my head. I still box people in.

Look earlier women who had it in them to become scientists were told explicitly that they should become housewives. Take a look at Joan Feynman; her thesis adviser told her the only geometry she needed to learn was the geometry of the cobwebs she should be cleaning at home. Imagine what would have happened if she would have given up. We would have lost a great mind to something as abhorrent as prejudice.

The same lesson still exists. Let the kid be. Let her grow up into who she wants to be. Not who society thinks she ought to be. She will be depressed if you take the fight out of her so that you can squeeze her into a housewife. She will be depressed if you force her onto a stage against her wish. She will be depressed in all the cases where you push her into becoming something she isn't. I think that this is what you were trying to say.

On the other hand, what boggles my mind is why aren't more males taught to exit their boxes and give a hand in raising their kids. Raising a human being isn't a full time job if it's a shared responsibility and I think expecting anything other than that is just another small box.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by caf on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @05:49AM (#1632426)
Aye - being a stay-at-home husband and father ought to be as equally socially acceptable as wife & mother.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by megablast on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @06:46AM (#1632479)
No, I am sorry it is not. Anybody can stay at home. Not anyone can start up a company, or work at a senior level, or even work at a technical level. There are plenty of people who could never achieve that level of competence, they can stay at home.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by moron4hire on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:13AM (#1632595)
I know a lot of terrible parents, and they aren't all dead-beats or alcoholics, they're just assholes who treat their families like shit. If one of the parental figures is an emotionally abusive person, then it'd probably be a net benefit to the family if that person were a workaholic who doesn't spend much time with the kids. Sure, they probably shouldn't have had a family in the first place, but it doesn't always work out that way. Not just anyone can stay at home and raise the family.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by dhimes on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @06:57AM (#1632495)
I strongly disagree. It should be the choice of the man, or at least of the family. Society shouldn't punish men socially for making that choice.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by mortenjorck on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:38AM (#1632916)
I hear running a startup and raising kids both tend to involve rather significant amounts of drive, talent, and time investment to be successful.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by snowbird122 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @07:33PM (#1634519)
This poster didn't say that anyone could be good at staying at home. They said anyone can stay at home. I think this is true and don't understand the downvotes.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by pyre on Thursday August 26, 2010 @02:25AM (#1635245)
Saying 'no' to making it more socially acceptable for a man to be a stay-at-home dad, and then going on about how 'not everyone can do X' seems to make the following statement indirectly:

  Only men are capable of (starting up a company | working at a senior
  level | working at a technical level). There are plenty of people who
  could never achieve that level of competence (namely women), they
  can stay at home.
Unless the poster is making that (very sexist) statement, then I fail to see how he/she is in disagreement with the poster they were responding to. Saying that it shouldn't be socially acceptable for people with great skills to let them languish by becoming a stay-at-home dad is not the same as saying that it should not be socially acceptable at all for a man to be a stay-at-home dad. [ Though in general, the idea that society should pressure people to make decisions that are only in society's best short-term interests. Who's to say that someone working at the 'senior level' is making a larger contribution to society then someone that stays at home to raise the next generation? ]
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by run4yourlives on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:32PM (#1633866)
Something tells me you do not have a family.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by sdelmont on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:13PM (#1633993)
something tells me he will never have a family
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by wake_up_sticky on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:05AM (#1632845)
While I agree that we shouldn't put people into boxes (figuratively or literally), the problem with what you're suggesting is that people become depressed when they don't know what society expects of them. This may be inconvenient, but it's true. Telling someone, "You can do whatever you want with your life; we're not going to tell you what to do" is effectively telling them, "We're not going to tell you what society values and expects from you; you won't get any guidance from us." It can be almost as bad to have too much choice as it is to have too little.
Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by todayiamme on Thursday August 26, 2010 @07:35AM (#1635645)
Actually, this is a fallacy that you start believing the traditional parenting point of view. I think that a parent's role is basically teaching the kids how to make the right choice. Not making the choice for them.

It's true that early on you need to nurture and protect them by taking stuff into your hands, but by the age they need to start thinking about stuff like this. They should be mature enough to do that, because you can't be there for them all their life telling them what to do, can you? It's just that your role as a nurturer needs to evolve with time as the dynamics of the relationship changes, and you need to respect that. Not fight it.

Re:How a call girl can earn far more by actually working far... by wake_up_sticky on Saturday August 28, 2010 @09:10AM (#1641714)
The problem is that there are an overwhelming number of choices when it comes to what to do with one's life. Parents need to at least make it clear that there's a relatively small subset of these choices which are acceptable. (Not a handful of choices, but maybe a couple dozen or so.)