I think you're underestimating the value of organizing the information into one place. And I'm sure there are/will be other features than just picture sharing.
> I dont think people would be comfortable with idea of sending it to a third party website...facebook album with proper privacy settings is much better option
This strikes me as a tad contradictory. People wouldn't trust a third party with these pictures but facebook is somehow okay.
Finally a person savvy enough to use such website/ email based service, must already be proficient with Facebook settings.
The problem is that you can twiddle the knobs and dials, but you have no confidence that they are connected to anything. Or that, if connected today, they will remain connected tomorrow. Facebook has made it clear that your privacy settings are not particularly important to them. They change the settings mechanism and defaults every six months, and somehow every such change tends to start leaking information for advertising or SEO purposes. Why, it's almost as if Facebook was being run by this guy:
Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg told a live audience yesterday that if he were to create Facebook again today, user information would by default be public, not private as it was for years until the company changed dramatically in December.
Also, you leave out the possibility that Facebook might alter the privacy settings without warning, which could catch even a savvy user by surprise.
Overall, I can't say I'll be participating in either activity though.
Also how is sending a link or notification about new pictures different from sending actual images. In case a group link is created.
It is unlikely that without notifications, people will actually go and browse the link for new pictures. In that case isn't it same as posting it on your Facebook profile as an album with appropriate privacy settings?
Exactly. I think the point is that FB's privacy settings are difficult for the average user to understand. FB also has a public-by-default policy, whereas The Fridge appears to be the opposite.
What about the situation where someone in a group goes 'rogue' and invites people who other group members don't want to see their stuff? These new members will see everything already posted... I think it's an important principle that anything you post to a group should only be visible to members of the groups _at that time_... otherwise you have no real control over the info you share.
I think this is superior due to the simplicity of the privacy settings.
The main benefit I see is for events and occasions where multiple people want to share photos. They can all be uploaded to a single location/group rather than spread out among several different facebook albums. In addition, only the users within the group can view them. You could be diligent in the privacy settings for the photos you upload yourself, but your friend might not be and the photos could still be viewed by mutual acquaintances.
Posterous works because people actually intend to publish their thoughts, and they are uncomfortable with using an web interface. But in case of picture I dont think people would be comfortable with idea of sending it to a third party website, why not just add multiple emails addresses to your 'to' field. also threaded conversations make it easier to have all comments / replies in a single place.
Also facebook album with proper privacy settings is much better option.