Re:The Sun is changing the rate of radioactive decay
by loewenskind on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @06:02AM
(#1632436)
But that means you're expecting the C14 rates to be the same now as when the subject died. A reasonable assumption but as far as I understand C14 hasn't reached any kind of equilibrium for some reason. Aren't there different amounts in the air than say, 50 years ago?
Re:The Sun is changing the rate of radioactive decay
by Confusion on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:46PM
(#1633737)
Carbon dating always requires an estimate of the initial amount of C14 in the object whose age is being determined. That is an issue separate from the one being considered in this thread, but one whose error bar is probably more important. I cursorily touched upon that with:
*x* is the initial amount of C14 we obtained via other means.
These 'other means' are thoroughly explained in various places on the web, due to the amount of creationist attacks on carbon dating.
* we measure differences of 1/1000th in decay rates (this is reasonable given the differences the article is based on)
* the average variation is 1/1000th, otherwise it would have been detected earlier.
* the halflife of C14 is 5000 years (to make calculations easy)
* we are determining the age of something 20000 years old (carbon dating is only used for ages in that order of magnitude).
* the decay formula is y = x(1/2)^(t/tau), where y is the amount of C14 you will measure after t years, tau is the halflife in years and x is the initial amount of C14 we obtained via other means.
We measure an amount of C14 that's 2^4 times smaller than current amounts and conclude that the amount of C14 was halved 4 times. If the decay rate was actually 1/1000th larger on average, then we should have conclude that 2^(-4) = 1/2^(t/5005) or t = 20020 years. In other words: the error is as large as the relative seasonal variation, which is quite small already and probably falls well within the regular error bars.