News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Voice UI Is the Future. But When? by dingo_bat on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:30AM (#16307197)
Maybe not exactly voice, but natural language UI is definitely the future. It would be awesome if I could talk to git and tell it to do exactly what I want in English. Instead of rote-learning arcane incantations.
Re:Voice UI Is the Future. But When? by otabdeveloper1 on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:51AM (#16307290)
> It would be awesome if I could talk to git and tell it to do exactly what I want in English.

Considering that even high-IQ native English speakers have huge, huge problems "just doing what you want", even after explicit and unambiguous instructions -- don't hold your breath. (Maybe after the flying moon car.)

Re:Voice UI Is the Future. But When? by andrewfong on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:51AM (#16307287)
It depends on the complexity and dangers of the command. Git actually seems like a very poor candidate for natural language.

Consider: Legal documents initially began as natural language evaluated by very effective natural language processors (other people). Over time, as the edge cases and ambiguities built up, the language of law diverged to the point that legalese is hardly considered "natural" today.

Re:Voice UI Is the Future. But When? by rimliu on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:22AM (#16307649)
Natural language is very poor for anything requiring precision.
Re:Voice UI Is the Future. But When? by BjoernKW on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:56AM (#16307315)
I don't think that natural language is a useful interface for tools like Git. Natural language is inherently verbose and ambiguous. That's precisely what you don't want when using tools like that.

Natural language has a low signal to noise ratio compared to explicit verbs and keywords.

Git just has less than stellar usability when it comes to performing common actions. Most of that probably is intentional because on the other hand it affords you a great deal of flexibility. If you want to improve the usability of Git standard UI patterns like providing better keywords and shortcuts to frequently used features will suffice. It's just a matter of the design philosophy behind the tool.