News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The decline of the HN Community by tptacek on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @01:46PM (#1630512)
Respectfully (you posted anonymously, so I'm not sure this could be taken personally):

Navel-gazing comments like this have always been my least favorite part of HN.

There's no content here. "The best members of the community" --- who are they? Why are they the best? What aspect of their comments are being drowned out or replaced with the mundane?

Sure, there are answers to these questions. At least, things we can come up with, now that the questions have been posed. But your post doesn't address them up front. Instead, it spends much of its time dissecting a discussion of homelessness. I suspect that it's motivated more by dissatisfaction with one comment thread, rather than a careful consideration of the "Hacker News community".

Maybe we should consider carefully whether the deterioration of comment threads has something to do with the commenters, or whether it's a symptom of the site getting more permissive about the topics themselves. Maybe we shouldn't be spending our time talking about homelessness here.

There are no comments on this comment yet.