Yes, of course the coal hasn't existed forever, and before that the carbon was presumably part of the atmosphere. But that wasn't an atmosphere ever breathed by Homo Sapiens. We don't want to make sure the atmosphere matches that at earth's creation (it wasn't always even significantly oxygenated! and if we want to put back all the carbon that includes killing all life). We want to be sure our activity doesn't leave us with significant negative consequences.
It took 50-100 years for the glaciers to form. Global warming caused measurable disruption of the same ocean currents in 2016 and 2017.
So, replicating pre-ice age conditions, as you suggest we should, could easily lead to the collapse of most European states, and at least the northern half of the US.
Right, there was no coal when the earth formed. It's all former biomass and was part of the biosphere. So we need to burn it to actually be carbon neutral. I did offer a refutation of this...