News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homeless Experiment by peterwwillis on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:36AM (#1630068)
mainly i feel sorry for this guy because of how out of touch he is. he packs more to be homeless than i pack to go camping and basically tries to emulate whatever he finds to be a stereotypical homeless person. maybe he never worked in food service and thus didn't know american dumpsters are goldmines of safe, edible food?

more than anything, this seems like a feeble attempt at a rich person to do something they consider "crazy" so they can have a cool story to tell their friends over caviar. "oh wow, look how dirty i was! ha ha!" this guy needs to get over himself.

there's lots of reasons why people become homeless (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness#Contributing_cause...) and most well-off people simply don't think about the kind of problems people have to deal with just to survive. homelessness is a multi-faceted and complex issue which encompasses millions of people in different situations. there is no way to "see how they live", unless maybe you got some head trauma, a broken leg, asthma and were dumped somewhere you didn't know with no support system and no job skills (compounded perhaps by a self-medicating drug or alcohol habit).

do you want to help the homeless? tell your congressmen to pass laws that help them with their real life problems they need to overcome (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness#Problems_faced_by_...) before they can try to sustain themselves with a job and housing. donate to organizations which provide food and shelter to many instead of handing out money to individuals. give old clothes and supplies (like the backpack & sleeping bag he tossed) to goodwill or a local shelter. mainly the way people can help the homeless is by putting forth resources to help people learn how to elevate themselves above simply surviving, which most people eventually settle for compared to what seems like the immense difficulty of getting a stable job.

Re:Homeless Experiment by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @12:01PM (#1630160)
According to the article, most of the homeless he encountered didn't have the problems you describe. Black Mike, for instance, was fit enough to defeat Nev in a slap-boxing match. The author also never called upon his support system or job skills, so I'm not sure how they are relevant.

Also, according to his experience at various shelters, he seems to have a backpack full of stuff comparable to other homeless people. Some of the items (e.g., toothbrush) were given out free at the homeless shelter. According to you, various organizations will give out other items "like the backpack & sleeping bag he tossed".

The only item that seems out of place is the laptop/phone, but according to the article: "There are two guys openly playing on their laptops here [a shelter] and one guy with a portable DVD player watching a movie. Many people have cell phones and MP3 players. "

Why do you feel his attempt is "feeble"?

Re:Homeless Experiment by peterwwillis on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @01:28PM (#1630446)
most of the homeless he encountered isn't most of the homeless. it's a small subsection of homeless in two parts of his town. different parts of different towns have different kinds of homeless. the wikipedia article i linked to explains how a surge of homeless came about, many of them having mental or medical issues. many times those coming back from war have both and end up homeless. and sure, eating what little you can, living outside and a stay in prison may give you better reflexes than a rich computer geek who blogs about being homeless for a week.

i don't think many people anticipate being homeless and then go and buy homeless gear. they aren't going to pack themselves a homeless kit. i imagine one would acquire things as they wander, pick up other people's junk, get what they can in handouts, etc. by just buying this stuff you're giving yourself an advantage over the penniless. perhaps it was his interest in only doing this for a week that prompted this "self-donation", i dunno. i refer to this same point regarding phone/laptop/etc.

it's feeble because he didn't really appear homeless. he only did it for a week. he just tried to get into places that were more comfortable vs living like the people who were unfortunate enough not to win the lottery. in other words, he was basically trying to game the system and see how good life could be as a homeless person vs how life really is. he's intelligent, well prepared, aware of his surroundings. he doesn't have any particular handicap which could prevent him from eventually just finding stable work. he makes a good point that there are good resources for people who fall on hard times temporarily, but this doesn't account for the majority of homeless who stay homeless for an extended time (or indefinitely). and i found it feeble because he spent more time taking pictures of himself than getting to understand "the freaks" or anyone else but black mike.

Re:Homeless Experiment by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @01:53PM (#1630534)
i don't think many people anticipate being homeless and then go and buy homeless gear.

Neither did he. The items he packed into the backpack he had since middle school were a $5 sleeping bag he happened to have in the closet, a few clothes, eyeglasses, a toothbrush, toilet paper and brown sign paper. (I'm ignoring the laptop, phone, camera and notebook, which didn't seem to help him much and were there mainly for documentation purposes).

If I were facing a surprise eviction in 10 minutes, I'd be able to pack far more than that. And as you say, even if I didn't, such things would be available from "help the homeless" organizations.

he just tried to get into places that were more comfortable vs living like the people who were unfortunate enough not to win the lottery.

I missed the part of the story where winning a lottery was necessary to in the park and under a bridge.

I will grant you that his experience is not statistically representative of homelessness as a whole. It's also a poor simulation of mental illness (did he claim to be simulating mental illness?).

But I don't see why you conclude he didn't reasonably experience homelessness.

Re:Homeless Experiment by peterwwillis on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:38AM (#1632777)
he experienced homelessness. but through a crystal glass, behind a pompous facade, with the armor of reserves of cash and helpful, resourceful friends. based on the conclusions of his blog, i don't think he learned anything.

mainly i don't think you can compare one homeless situation to another and so this kind of "see what its like" scenario is not useful.

Re:Homeless Experiment by Tichy on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @02:47PM (#1630710)
Sure, he wasn't truly homeless. But he slept under a bridge and in a homeless shelter together with truly homeless people. How many people go to that length to try to learn something?

So even if his approach might have been flawed, I think his attempt should be applauded. Personally, I never even talk to homeless people, even if I pack all sorts of non-homeless gear.

Re:Homeless Experiment by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @03:24PM (#1630833)
Agreed. How can you not have a flawed approach to this experiment? At some level you know you are not truly homeless, and have a safety net.
Re:Homeless Experiment by dusklight on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @02:09PM (#1630585)
maybe you are right but isn't it good that some rich out-of-touch people are at least attempting to try to understand the situation, instead of pretending the homeless don't exist like so many of us do?
Re:Homeless Experiment by sandaru1 on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @02:29PM (#1630658)
> more than anything, this seems like a feeble attempt at a rich person to do something they consider "crazy" so they can have a cool story to tell their friends over caviar. "oh wow, look how dirty i was! ha ha!" this guy needs to get over himself.

Actually if you read the other entries of this guy's blog, you'll see that he is genuinely curious guy