Actually, my zsh config mostly behaves like fish with great completion, syntax coloring and sensible history handling, with zsh syntax which is close to bash. So I can copy paste stuff from the internet and reuse my knowledge from the time I used bash because it was the default, and still leverage the improvements brought by zsh.
I don't understand 2.
For 3, of course you should understand what you run, but I don't want my tools to get in the way. My tools should allow me to do what I want, not prevent me from doing something for technical reasons. This is a question of education. If people want to run something without understanding it, I bet they will type it blindly, if they can't copy paste it. They will just be slower at running things blindly, leading them to a disaster just a bit slower. Please let me not lose my time even more when I cause disasters.
(Yes, true, retyping stuff forces your more to think about it, but I already review the things I paste into my shell)
1) what you paste might not be exactly what you copied. i.e: http://thejh.net/misc/website-terminal-copy-paste
2) possible licensing issues
3) it enables cargo cult programming