1) Google (and other SV giants) share data with the NSA.
https://www.salon.com/2014/11/16/googles_secret_nsa_alliance...
2) The NSA in turn shares information with law-enforcement agencies. ICREACH contains information on the private communications millions of American citizens who have not been accused of any wrongdoing.
https://gizmodo.com/the-nsa-made-its-own-google-to-help-shar...
3) The DEA (and possibly other agencies) uses this information to target Americans, and then lies about the origins of the information in a process called "parallel construction."
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-dea-sod/exclusive-u-s-dir...
It's not difficult to see the potential for abuse in a shadowy process that surveils the private communications of Americans, applies unknown selectors and data mining algorithms, and then reports the results to law enforcement.
https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/
Speaking of spooky stuff and google, this article still takes the cake.
EDIT: for completeness sake, there has been a follow up:
I hate it when people use this as an argument against "Google invading privacy", it's an argument that doesn't make any sense at all; Encrypting your data in transit prevents outsiders from reading your data, obviously it doesn't prevent Google itself from accessing your data.
This article is about how Google (and FB, etc.) invades everyone's privacy (even non-customers).
> To me, the cost of being google's product, is outweighed by what they provide me with
This can also be achieved without invading your privacy. Google should at least let people CHOOSE whether they want to use their products at the cost of privacy. Currently you cannot choose, your data is simply collected, even when browsing websites totally unrelated to Google, where people are absolutely unaware of Google tracking them.
PS. This guy is awesome, he has had success fighting against Facebook, for privacy (in Europe):
Why should they let us do that? No other company is doing that. It's a tacit agreement between providers of free-to-use services and the people who choose to use them: the more personal data you give, the more you receive. If a company has a very good offering or is currently trending, they can even demand your phone number, credit card number (of course you can cancel the service anytime, but they will have a strong verification of your real name then) or even your passport/driver's license. We all came to accept that as a given, nobody questions these practices any longer. It's as if people collectively just stopped giving a damn about their privacy.
I think we really should start making it difficult for companies to grow beyond a certain size. I think they are a big net minus for the whole economy.
Of course, there might be a long history of larger companies getting disrupted by smaller companies outside of the tech industry, which would be much more compelling evidence than MySpace losing to Facebook, IBM losing the PC market to Microsoft, Microsoft losing mobile phones to Apple/Google, etc.
I am not willing to make a bet as to whether or not we will still be talking about Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Google, or Facebook 25, 50, or 100 years from now.
I like google's services. What I want is the ability to pay for them and not be a part of the product they sell in ads. Basically a freemium model.
I don't know how much money in ad revenue I earn google, but I'd probably happily pay it for a more transparent, less sketchy, and more commonly-aligned product. (This would also give me recourse for all the times the google services I rely on go down....)
You do have the ability to pay for some of them (G Suite aka Google Apps for Business), but even then you might not get what you want, since 99% of their users like you are still products. I'm reminded of this quote from Josh Marshall:
> One thing I’ve observed with Google over the years is that it is institutionally so used to its ‘customers’ actually being its products that when it gets into businesses where it actually has customers it really has little sense of how to deal with them. (https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-serf-on-googles-farm)
(Disclaimer: I'm a Googler but I just got these numbers from public statements. No way I'm well paid enough to be able to see more detailed numbers. :-D )
Are you criticizing Google or companies in general? Because your criticism applies to any company in the world.
> I like google's services. What I want is the ability to pay for them and not be a part of the product they sell in ads. Basically a freemium model.
Get a corporate gSuite account, they have been around for quite a while.
I don't think corp gsuite lets you opt out of ad targeting and general tracking (I could be wrong).
Then pay for it, stop using free services.
> I don't think corp gsuite lets you opt out of ad targeting and general tracking (I could be wrong).
AFAIK it doesn't use any info from the services you pay for to target you.
But remember, ads on websites aren't a form of paying for Google's services, but for the website content.
Do you read Ars Technica? Instead of seeing the ads you just subscribe to them. Read news online freely? Stop and pay for a few newspapers and only read them.
People knowingly choose free services that come with the tradeoff of ad targeting. That's how those services are paid. Using those services is your choice.
Apple, for example, has very strong incentives to maintain your privacy, to the point that they have made it a selling point for their devices and are also suffering in the realms of machine learning because they are not leveraging your data the way Google or FB would.
> their incentives aren't really aligned with yours
No, they have a very strong incentive to appear to maintain your privacy. And that's only temporary.
Don't fall for any company saying that they're doing something in the user's interests. They aren't. Companies exist to make profits, if for a brief period of time that means helping users in some way, it's only a coincidence, and you're being fooled by it.
Take a look at China, Apple didn't even blink before deciding to hand over all data to the Chinese government.
I trust companies, because I know exactly what matters for them: profits. I trust them to follow profits and act on their best interest.
For example, Yahoo was caught helping the US government spy on consumers, whether they were suspect or not: http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-yahoo-em...
What's more, Yahoo is now owned by Verizon, a company known for anti-consumer practices.
We should all make some easy changes:
- Use DuckDuckGo to get Yahoo /Bing search results in privacy
- Use StartPage.com to get Google search results in privacy
- Use a privacy-friendly email service
- Either quit FB or use it only as a billboard
- Get a Linux distro and avoid Windows OS when possible
- Try LibreOffice. It rivals Office!
etc.
- Use uBlock Origin when browsing the interwebs
- Use GoAccess instead of Google Analytics
- Use the incognito/private tab
Even if they aren't doing anything reprehensible now, can you guarantee that they won't in future?
The more info someone has on you (your preferences, habits, how price sensitive you are to certain products, ...), the more disadvantaged you are negotiating with them.
I mean, I'd still think about that even without FB showing me things, but I would not have managed to build a "here's a flashback!" photo-reminder system. In an age when we take SO MANY PHOTOS (and don't even bother curating them because we don't have time for it), it's nice to have that too.
I can see your point but it isn't relevant to the article, and also, it is a matter of perspective. I managed to permanently disable it, after it kept popping up photos of my then-recently deceased spouse. Not something I was ready to deal with, and after switching it off, FB helpfully turned it back on for me. I eventually managed to disable it permanently, but if there is one thing I hate it is for some software to treat my instructions as suggestions.
You wouldn't have had to if you used macOS with the Photos app. Every once in a while it notifies me about a flashback, and if I click on the notification it takes me to a flashback slideshow in the Photos app.
I don't use iCloud for my photos, so I suspect this is implemented locally without having to give my data to Apple.
Maybe similar systems exist with other environments (linux, Windows, etc).
I block everything to do with Facebook every which way on my primary browser.
yes, in fact they have become almost absolute monopolists (together with FB and a couple of others).
this is really bad.. if google decides not to show you something _it effectively does not exist_
i _really_ hope they still have the mantra of not being evil, but the temptation is trillions of dollars big :)
if they abuse your information, e.g. use it as fore knowledge, and act on it quicker than you can, they can do that in subtle ways without you even realising it.
so many ways to benefit from all this data.. who can monitor / control this?
I prefer my data be at one place as much as possible instead scattered.
Easisest place to do that is with Google as they have the most comprehensive services.
The NSA proved them wrong on that belief, and they started implementing encryption on those connections.
I think their biggest sins are just being big. It makes them a larger target (which probably necessitates them taking extreme protections, otherwise they WOULD be taken down). Others that are much more concerning don't get attacked simply because they are smaller. For example Lyft and Uber who have both been found to have all sorts of personally identifiable information available to random employees. Or various ISPs tracking of data flowing through it.
To me, the cost of being google's product, is outweighed by what they provide me with. Search, news, music, assistant functions, "remember this day", "here is your family growing up", e-mail, automation of e-mails into actionable widgets... These things all are powered by Google knowing kind of a lot about me.
I don't know of any alternative to Google for these services, that respects privacy.