The assumption that anyone who might have anything important to say would be at an academic institution is extremely dangerous (just as is the problem of access to journals outside of academic institutions, etc.).
My suggestion: use ORCiD.org for authentication with OAuth. This is a researcher profile. Most academics have one (or should!). They're free, the service is open. I think it strikes the right balance between barrier-to-entry for spam and accessibility.
Academic journal papers are meant to be digested by experts in that topic, not the general population. It seems necessary to have a filter on registration to ensure that the platform is useful to these experts. You could imagine the restriction could be relaxed to research institution emails -or- a referral.
Even with a restrictive registration, the platform could still be useful to the a non-expert who is interested in the topic by reading the exchanges between experts.
TL;DR: Studies like these need scrutiny from everyone. Not just people that declare themselves experts.
I disagree.The latest E-Cig study says they found evidence of tumors in mice who were exposed to cigarette smoke....What they don't tell you in the abstract is that they used 10mg/ml nicotine E-juice and exposed the mice for 3h/day, for 12 weeks. The highest ratio most people vape at is 9mg/ml. No one smokes them for 3 hours straight. The study failed to include how exactly they produce the vapor, no mention of wicking material or coil metallurgy, temperature, or voltage of the coil. It could very well be that the tumors were cause by combustion of either the coil being heated above it's melting point, the wicking material burning, or the juice being combusted and not vaporized. Even though I'm not considered an expert in tumors or cancer I have learned that this test is flawed is missing information and doesn't really show anything that we as people don't already know "Heating things beyond the combustion point produces byproducts that could be harmful to our health." I can rest assured instead of listening to headlines that didn't bother to read or scrutinize the study. I think studies like these need scrutiny from everyone. Not just people that declare themselves experts.
Let's also be fair...just because I have an academic email address doesn't mean I'm an expert. I could be a janitor at JHU for intent and purposes.
I have to agree. I'm no academic for almost 10 years, now, yet I've spent the last three years working with academics on my free time and it's really frustrating how hard it is to work without a “proper” affiliation. I've had to create my own “lab” (it's just a name, and it's only me) to have my name on posters, but I'm still unable to get access to some services because, well… because I'm not paid for the work I do, I guess.
She's getting paid a reasonable amount. She gets paid overtime. Her opinions are given weight. Her physical needs are taken seriously. She gets credit for her work. She is, in general, treated as an actual human being capable of having expertise and bringing value.
The total result is that she's spent months going "WHY DID NOBODY TELL ME THE PRIVATE SECTOR WAS AWESOME?!"
- A tool for annotation so that people could comment on specific portions of papers. This could help new researchers in a field to more quickly understand the different broader contexts in which a result can be interpreted, or the technical limitations of a given method and how that should be considered when say using the results to motivate other work.
- An option for some form of anonymised commentary, so that people could voice their views on a particular work without fear of reprisal. I think this would be amazing for non-tenured academics to exert some form of power in the community, if a platform like this were to take off. Of course, it would make for potentially very messy and difficult to moderate discussions.
The basic problem is that I was constantly finding myself struggling with a tricky part of some paper from the 70's ("Why is this sentence true??"), and I knew many students before me had struggled with the same section, but there was no way for one really great expositor to clarify it, get upvoted, and be done.
Swot is a community-driven or crowdsourced library for verifying that domain names and email addresses are tied to a legitimate university of college - more specifically, an academic institution providing higher education in tertiary, quaternary or any other kind of post-secondary education in any country in the world.
https://gist.github.com/danielecook/19793d2faad66d83cef2514c...
Those are used in many places as a simple way to validate that you are a student or a researcher.
@bringtheaction comment mentioning SWOT is an interesting solution. Although the name of my institution is outdated! I'll send a PR.
I have been involved in academia for 10 years now, and I never held an email address that would match against the SWOT list.
Or you can crowdsource this, say I want to register as [email protected]; in the registration form simply require me to give a link to someone's Google Scholar profile with an email address from the same domain.
It should also be noted that e.g. on Figshare, anyone can upload any PDF and get a DOI for it.
Many papers list authors' email addresses.
Scrape PDFs on the services you support for email addresses. If a domain name occurs in enough author email addresses and isn't on a "known generic" list (gmail et al), consider it "safe".
* arXiv * bioRxiv * Pubmed * Pubmed Central * DOI
Threads are submitted using the publication ID, DOI, or URL of a pre-print or publication. PDFs are fetched when available and used to generate a thumbnail.
Currently, the site only supports academic email addresses. I am trying to figure out the best way to open the site to all without having to manage spam. Let me know if you have any thoughts/ideas. If you are interested in accessing the site and do not have an academic email address please PM me with an email address to whitelist.