News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ruby's Date/DateTime classes rewritten in C.. 20-200x per... by bad_user on Monday August 23, 2010 @11:58AM (#1627108)

     You compare a many thousand man years VM (HotSpot JVM) 
     to one that has been largely written by one person in 
     isolation ( Ruby 1.8 series ).
LuaJIT was also written by "one person in isolation" and yet it beats Java in some benchmarks.

There are techniques first researched in the Smalltalk/Self implementations that have been known for at least 20 years (roughly the same time Ruby was born) that could've been used in Ruby 1.9.

     Ruby 1.9 has 90% of the features you mention above and 
     RBX will soon remove the GIL on top of it.
You're talking as if there's a list of checkboxes that just needs to be checked.

It doesn't work that way.

One reason the GIL is here to stay is because of the many libraries written in C that depend on it.

Another reason would be performance degradation on single threaded programs ... removing the GIL on the whole needs major architectural changes ... just putting fine-grained locks on all mutable data structures won't cut it.

And yet another would be the garbage collector which also needs to be optimized for true multi-threading, otherwise it becomes a bottleneck. So add this on your list ... Ruby also needs a top-notch generational garbage-collector.

     Async IO is arguably further along in Ruby then in Java
You are probably kidding.
Re:Ruby's Date/DateTime classes rewritten in C.. 20-200x per... by xal on Monday August 23, 2010 @12:31PM (#1627192)
It's odd to point to C extensions when talking about the need for a GIL.

The solution seems obvious. Wrap them in a mutex by default and introducing an optional API call to remove the lock.

This way the important libraries will be fixed up gradually by the community and after a bit of time you won't have any C ext's left that will make use of the mutex and therefore the GIL will be gone.

That's the approach that rubinius is set to take.

Re:Ruby's Date/DateTime classes rewritten in C.. 20-200x per... by lg on Monday August 23, 2010 @03:02PM (#1627665)
rbx will use the immix collector
Re:Ruby's Date/DateTime classes rewritten in C.. 20-200x per... by rue on Monday August 23, 2010 @03:50PM (#1627809)
Uses.