News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hawaii’s false missile alert sent by worker believing att... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 30, 2018 @01:01PM (#16267372)
> Confirmation screens might have given the operator a moment's pause to consider whether or not they were certain.

There was a confirmation screen.

I have seen no suggestion how a different confirmation than actually existed would have helped, and I don't think we want to introduce more delay in the critical path of a live alert without clear and massive benefit.

> A UI that makes it easy to make a mistake, even when the mistake is intended, and makes it almost impossible to correct that mistake, is a badly designed UI.

The problem with correcting the mistake is not a UI problem, but a deeper planning and procedure problem.

Re:Hawaii’s false missile alert sent by worker believing att... by krapp on Tuesday January 30, 2018 @01:37PM (#16267716)
> and I don't think we want to introduce more delay in the critical path of a live alert without clear and massive benefit.

If that delay reduces false alarms, when false alarms erode public trust in and concern about the alert system, then the massive benefit is clear. With such a system, drills and tests are going to be massively more common than actual events. Designing the UI so that the one-in-a-million option is as easy to invoke as the once-every-week option is a UI problem.

Notwithstanding it not being a primary issue in this particular case, I believe it's still an issue worth discussing.

Also, bear in mind that correcting the "deeper planning and procedural problems" would introduce delays as well. Anything but a purely automated system, or a big red button would introduce some delay.

Re:Hawaii’s false missile alert sent by worker believing att... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 30, 2018 @01:46PM (#16267793)
> Also, bear in mind that correcting the "deeper planning and procedural problems" would introduce delays as well

No, it wouldn't, because those are problems that impact after an alert is issued, and whose existence caused delays in sending an all-clear. Resolving them won't effect the path prior to an alert, and would eliminate rather than introduce delays.