News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Personas Fail by jerf on Monday January 29, 2018 @10:13AM (#16257899)
Yes, the very idea that customers can be bucketed is flawed. We are all unique people.

But we do not categorize our customers into buckets because we are denying their individuality. We do it because we lack the cognitive firepower to address several thousand people individually, by multiple orders of magnitude. Categorization isn't a denial of their humanity, it's an acknowledgement of our humanity, as opposed to being some sort of post-Singularity AI or Deity that is capable of individually addressing people. We have no options to address this flaw.

Pretending that we've just got one user who wants to routinely buy Depends, yet at others for no apparent reason, is intensely into punk rock, and on another day forgets how to speak English and is only going to interact with your site in Tagalog, is just going to distort your UI in other ways. I don't think acknowledging people's individuality is accomplished by only acknowledging one individual, with that individual constructed in such a way that this one individual is representative of nobody.

Re:Why Personas Fail by TeMPOraL on Monday January 29, 2018 @10:59AM (#16258197)
I think GP is fine with bucketing, but they're saying that f(age, gender, interests, ...) is not a good hashing function.

I haven't seen studies on the topic, but on the surface of it, I'm inclined to agree - it doesn't seem to be a good bucketing strategy, and unless we're talking about cold-calling/edge of the funnel, and painting in very broad strokes, it misses the most important factor uniting them all - they're on your site, so they must want something. Hence, "we should use criteria based on what people are trying to achieve right now".

Re:Why Personas Fail by kruhft on Monday January 29, 2018 @11:40AM (#16258512)
Sounds like a problem for Expert Systems.
Re:Why Personas Fail by bambax on Monday January 29, 2018 @11:16AM (#16258319)
Yes, exactly.