Re:The Quantum Theory and Reality (1979) [pdf]
by lmm on Monday January 29, 2018 @07:42AM
(#16257122)
> where the heck are all these squillions of universe copies every second and where does the energy come from and go to making squillions of universes worth of matter and creating universe sized places to put them
It's the same "mass" of universe, just split across squillions of pieces. Like a tree trunk dividing into two branches, or a river confluence in reverse. (In fact it makes no difference if there were always two universe branches, it's just that they happened to contain exactly the same physical events up until the point where they didn't). And actually it's continuous rather than discrete: most of the time rather than dividing into distinct branches it's more like it's spreading out across a landscape. The branches are an approximation to let us compute more easily rather than something fundamental (e.g. we take this big continuous landscape of "universes" and draw a line between the region where a given photon was up and the region where that photon was down, and treat this as two distinct universes, because what we're interested in is whether the photon was up or down, and for our purposes any two points in the universe-landscape in which the photon was up are equivalent to each other).
> how does you interacting with a photon on Earth cause a copy of the Andromeda galaxy anyway?
It doesn't; when you interact with the photon which is, from your perspective, in two forks, you entangle your own fate with it, and from the perspective of an observer in Andromeda, both you and the photon are now in two forks (the one where the photon was up and you measured it as up, and the one where the photon was down and you measured it as down). As and when the observer in Andromeda interacts with you, then they can also be seen as divided into two forks. But if the observer in Andromeda is behaving exactly the same way in either fork, then it makes more sense to see them as being in a single unified universe. (Again, the very concept of "forks" is a simplification over continuous reality; the point isn't that there's any concrete sense in which the observer in Andromeda is in one rather than two realities whereas you are in two rather than one, it's just that when we want to talk about you we can draw a line in the universe landscape (between universes in which you measured up and universes in which you measured down) and treat the universe landscape as a fork between two universes, while when we want to talk about the observer in Andromeda there is no value in using that particular model (though there's nothing wrong with doing so, and if you compute predictions about the observer in Andromeda while treating them as being in such a superposition you will obtain correct results)).
It's the same "mass" of universe, just split across squillions of pieces. Like a tree trunk dividing into two branches, or a river confluence in reverse. (In fact it makes no difference if there were always two universe branches, it's just that they happened to contain exactly the same physical events up until the point where they didn't). And actually it's continuous rather than discrete: most of the time rather than dividing into distinct branches it's more like it's spreading out across a landscape. The branches are an approximation to let us compute more easily rather than something fundamental (e.g. we take this big continuous landscape of "universes" and draw a line between the region where a given photon was up and the region where that photon was down, and treat this as two distinct universes, because what we're interested in is whether the photon was up or down, and for our purposes any two points in the universe-landscape in which the photon was up are equivalent to each other).
> how does you interacting with a photon on Earth cause a copy of the Andromeda galaxy anyway?
It doesn't; when you interact with the photon which is, from your perspective, in two forks, you entangle your own fate with it, and from the perspective of an observer in Andromeda, both you and the photon are now in two forks (the one where the photon was up and you measured it as up, and the one where the photon was down and you measured it as down). As and when the observer in Andromeda interacts with you, then they can also be seen as divided into two forks. But if the observer in Andromeda is behaving exactly the same way in either fork, then it makes more sense to see them as being in a single unified universe. (Again, the very concept of "forks" is a simplification over continuous reality; the point isn't that there's any concrete sense in which the observer in Andromeda is in one rather than two realities whereas you are in two rather than one, it's just that when we want to talk about you we can draw a line in the universe landscape (between universes in which you measured up and universes in which you measured down) and treat the universe landscape as a fork between two universes, while when we want to talk about the observer in Andromeda there is no value in using that particular model (though there's nothing wrong with doing so, and if you compute predictions about the observer in Andromeda while treating them as being in such a superposition you will obtain correct results)).