News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence that the brain’s ability to control thinking rel... by wolco on Sunday January 28, 2018 @02:39PM (#16253023)
I would love to see someone reply with personal experience. I have tried similiar apps for extremely brief periods and could feel a change.
Re:Evidence that the brain’s ability to control thinking rel... by yoz-y on Monday January 29, 2018 @12:33AM (#16255522)
Personal experience is the bane of science. And plural of “anectode” is “anectodes”, not “data”.

Having worked in the field for years, I am pretty sure that listening to some sound at some frequency might induce that rhythm in the appropriate part of the brain (I have worked on SSVEP which is the same thing for visual stimuli, and is easily detectable, there is also some evidence that it could work for sensory motor stimuli).

However, inducing some frequency somewhere in the brain is pretty useless. Beta activity has been known for some time as the “activity” indicator. But this is simply because that is the working frequency of the brain. Active means just that, is it good is it bad? That depends.

One thing that strikes me in the field is how sure people are that anything “induced” in the brain will be positive. If the binaural beats thing really worked, then you would have as much chance to create depression as a sense of calmness.

Re:Evidence that the brain’s ability to control thinking rel... by abusoufiyan on Monday January 29, 2018 @12:37AM (#16255534)
> Personal experience is the bane of science. And plural of “anectode” is “anectodes”, not “data”.

And yet, eugenics was kind of heavily touted by scientists precisely because of an inability to accept as valid the personal experiences of the populations it targeted.

Re:Evidence that the brain’s ability to control thinking rel... by mostlyskeptical on Sunday January 28, 2018 @03:08PM (#16253161)
The placebo effect is still an effect.
Re:Evidence that the brain’s ability to control thinking rel... by RBerenguel on Sunday January 28, 2018 @05:53PM (#16254095)
Yup. I use this app sparingly, and I feel a mild effect. And actually I don’t care if it’s placebo (likely) or not, since it kind of works as I want