News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Functioning ‘mechanical gears’ seen in nature (2013) by totalZero on Sunday January 28, 2018 @07:53AM (#16251088)
That doesn't seem like a good definition.

If I pick up a baby bear in the woods and play with it for a moment before its mom finds out, does it cease to be natural?

If I don a wig, am I covering my unnatural hair with artificial hair?

Re:Functioning ‘mechanical gears’ seen in nature (2013) by coldtea on Sunday January 28, 2018 @09:10AM (#16251352)
>That doesn't seem like a good definition.

There's no such thing as a "good" definition. We begin with the definition, not with some pre-existing concept (which would require an earlier definition of the same thing).

The definition is what it is: just a name we use to collect certain phenomena together.

Re:Functioning ‘mechanical gears’ seen in nature (2013) by LukaCEnzo on Sunday January 28, 2018 @10:58AM (#16251761)
I think that the disagreement stems from the difference between what you and him mean by definition.

We use words to describe, and to categorize stuff. But naturally this vague. Everybody undestands if you describe a shirt as blue.or green, but most people would find it hard to describe when one turns to another, where the boundary between them is. So we use other names for that, or describe it as blueish green, or something similar.

To get rid of confusion, handle edge cases, and for other reasons, we define formal defenitions, which are different from the ambiguous idea we have of something.

What the comment you replied to means, is that the formal definition doesn't fit his idea of what is natural. You on the other hand are saying that the formal definition is the only (valid) meaning of the word, and so it can't be good or bad.

Re:Functioning ‘mechanical gears’ seen in nature (2013) by totalZero on Monday January 29, 2018 @02:32PM (#16260005)
Yes.

Not to mention that "anything untouched by humans" is not the formal definition of "natural."

Re:Functioning ‘mechanical gears’ seen in nature (2013) by totalZero on Monday January 29, 2018 @02:31PM (#16259990)
> There's no such thing as a "good" definition.

This is completely useless.

> We begin with the definition

No. We begin with a name, used to describe a particular entity, phenomenon, or class thereof. As the name comes into greater use, its meaning becomes known through some measure of positive (this is X) and near miss (this is like X, but not X), and eventually a definition is clarified that attempts to capture those linkages between the word and the represented things.