Bill Gates was successful and dropped out of college. He was also hard working and curious. Does that mean that everybody else who's hard working and curious will be as successful without a diploma? I wouldn't bet on it.
Also, having a desire to be in the right place at the right time doesn't guarantee that you'll do just that.
I agree that having a diploma is not what is going to make you successful. But at least, it gives you better odds to beat economic troubles, which is the point of the article.
Most likely they're in the negative space though, the part of the 'employed'.
If we could all be that lucky, then sure, college would be worthless. But there's a hundred million people for each one of those who want to have something instead of all or nothing.
Moreover, among those senators and babble-recyclers in the media, let me assure you, none of them are Bill Gates.
The author is saying that nobody anywhere close to Washington power centers has any perspective on this.
For every Bill Gates there are millions of people cleaning toilets and working at McDonald's.
You can stick labels fairly easily on the various degrees, they may not mean much in terms of practical knowledge but they do put up a lower boundary that they had to cross. For auto-didacts you run the gamut all the way from incompetent bumbler to ace, and there is no foolproof way to separate those when looking at large groups but it will make a huge difference to the outcome of the study.
Especially in the IT sector there is a lot of "I am an 'x'" where X is anything from the set of recent buzzwords.
So I don't think you can make even that comparison in an easy and reliable way, what people call themselves may not be what they actually are.
Who cares? Notice that they didn't mention Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Mary Kay, Richard Branson, Michael Dell, Walt Disney, Henry Ford, Frank Lloyd Wright - who arguably have all contributed more to this country than our established political leaders recently. Clearly this is the washington post - but the myopic view of looking at the political arena, if anything - shows what is wrong with associating college with "smart, capable, and adding value to our country." I'm just saying that many people in the US are not proud of legislators - and saying that they all went to college hardly proves a good point.
Hard work, natural curiosity, caring about your community, a desire to learn and being in the right place at the right time has more to do with being successful and adding value to our society than becoming part of the "College club" that is Washington.