Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by alexkearns on Saturday August 21, 2010 @02:43PM
(#1623370)
And you, sir, ought to be careful not to be so condescending.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by loup-vaillant on Sunday August 22, 2010 @08:53AM
(#1624561)
Sorry, but my options were limited: I felt I had to say unpleasant things, and I meant it in a good way. That's pretty much the definition of condescension.
So, it's either being condescending or not pointing out your mistakes at all. Do you really think you would have done otherwise? http://xkcd.com/386/
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by alexkearns on Monday August 23, 2010 @03:40PM
(#1627769)
Are you always this annoying?
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by loup-vaillant on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:25AM
(#1629857)
Allways, no. The last few days, yes. In the future, I hope not.
It feels like I am more and more able to see flaws in other's reasoning, but it's still harder to see them in mine. I also didn't figure out a way of saying "you're wrong" which doesn't hurt people yet. Finally, my current priority on the internet is seeking truth, not being nice.
So I guess that makes me an arrogant jerk. Well that's not cool, maybe I should shift my priorities a bit.
To the point, I think you and the author disagree on some definitions. Most likely "writing code" and "lines of code that make it to the final product". Plus the unspoken assumptions about the project (small or large, early or late…), but that has already been pointed out.
I also don't think the article suggests that "a great programmer is someone who connects together bits of code created by others, rather than writing his own code". What It does suggest is that great programmers don't write their own code when they shouldn't. That when they do anyway, it's probably out of laziness (screw the searching, I prefer coding), or arrogance (I can do better anyway), or ignorance (what? It has been done before?).
You are right to ridicule those who utter bullshit while claiming it's universal truths. But be careful not to leave holes in your rebuttal. That include angry tone and amplifying the opponent's words.