Re:Car insurers accused of discriminating against people wit...
by fpig on Thursday January 25, 2018 @07:11AM
(#16230306)
I said that even if it was scientifically proven it still wouldn't be OK to discriminate. Reading comprehension.
And the discussion was NOT about systems using correlation as a heuristic for causation. If a company filters users based on something, only correlation matters for their purposes. Believing correlation is only useful as a heuristic for causation is ignorant. For some purposes, correlation matters. For some purposes, the root cause matters. Not everything is the same.
> and this was scientifically proven
which renders moot any discussion as you simply did not use the same assumptions. The discussion was about specialist decision systems using correlation as a heuristic for causation. You cannot explore the merit (or shortfalls) of this common practice and its possible effect on policy-making when positing that causation has been proven. This is nonsense.
Have a good day.