News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Smear campaign against Wikileaks begins by yummyfajitas on Saturday August 21, 2010 @09:35AM (#1622811)
That does a disservice to the very large number of rape victims out there.

You are attempting to shut down discussion by asking for sympathy for rape victims. It is logically a non-sequitur and is just an appeal to emotion.

According to the wikipedia summary of the studies, 8% of accusations where the accuser cooperates result in the police concluding they were false.

These numbers explicitly exclude cases where the charges are dropped or where the accuser does not cooperate with the police. Since false accusers are likely to do both those things (to avoid being revealed as a liar), the scenario being studied excludes many false accusations. Additionally, there are likely to be false accusations where the police are unable to determine whether they are false.

8% is almost certainly a lower bound.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_accusation_of_rape

Re:Smear campaign against Wikileaks begins by jacquesm on Saturday August 21, 2010 @11:01AM (#1622962)
Most = > 50%.

> You are attempting to shut down discussion by asking for sympathy for rape victims.

No, I merely pointed out that there are plenty of rape cases that are real and that pretending that the majority of rape cases are faked is not exactly realistic.

Rape is a tough thing to confront, even if it is real and there are a very large number of rape cases that are never even brought to the stage of accusation.

True rape cases also have many instances where charges are dropped or where the accuser will not cooperate with the police because it is simply too painful.

Re:Smear campaign against Wikileaks begins by yummyfajitas on Saturday August 21, 2010 @12:06PM (#1623091)
I'm not disputing that "most" is unproven. I'm just pointing out your appeal to emotion.

At least 1 in 10 rape accusers are liars. Pointing out this fact does not do a disservice to actual rape victims. It simply gives us a prior for determining whether these women are actually rape victims.

(I.e., before knowing any facts about this case, we can conclude that a rape accuser is 92% likely to deserve sympathy and 8% likely to deserve jail time.)