News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by wincy on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @09:58AM (#16223135)
If I recall he waged war against God with part of the hosts of heaven? Who were then corrupted and cast down to Hell with Satan.

It’s been a couple months since I read Paradise Lost though.

Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by anentropic on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @10:09AM (#16223222)
But so what? Where is the evil?
Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by taneq on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @10:20AM (#16223294)
I believe in this context, "evil" means "against God" or "not according to God's will" (though how that's possible when God is defined as omnipotent, I don't understand) and so doesn't align with our own usual moral compass which defines evil as some variant of "hurting people".
Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by dagw on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @10:40AM (#16223480)
The war against God is not the primary source of his 'Evil'. His choice to get revenge on God by corrupting man and getting man cast out of paradise is probably his canonical 'evil' act.
Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by jessaustin on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @01:27PM (#16224998)
As pointed out above, the serpent isn't necessarily named "Satan". However, it isn't really objective to call the act you describe, "evil". It might have been harmful to humanity to have been kicked out of the garden. (Although, if that hadn't happened, would we have iPhones now? One can see both sides of this question!) The fact we are sinful enough to disobey instructions about eating fruit is more about who we are than about anything the serpent did. If a child destroys a poorly-built house by kicking it, do we blame the child? Why would God want such fragile creatures in his garden in the first place?
Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by dagw on Thursday January 25, 2018 @03:00AM (#16229475)
As pointed out above, the serpent isn't necessarily named "Satan"

Are we talking about the bible or Milton? I agree it's not clear in the bible, but feel Milton makes it quite clear.

It might have been harmful to humanity to have been kicked out of the garden

I'm not even really sure that's the point. 'Humanity' is a third party in that fight. God had built this new, fragile creature, the 'best' thing he'd ever made. He realized they where fragile and put them in the garden to protect them. Satan is pissed off at God for casting him out and decided to fuck with God by breaking his new toy that he knows God is very proud of. None of them seem to care too much about the long term fate of humanity.

If a child destroys a poorly-built house by kicking it, do we blame the child?

If a child destroys an extremely fragile work of art, do we blame the artist for not making his art more robust.

Re:Milton's Morality: Fallen Man and the Fallen Stature of '... by jessaustin on Thursday January 25, 2018 @12:33PM (#16232673)
You (and Milton, perhaps?) are assuming more about God and God's motivations than is present in the source material. We're told that He "loves" us, but that didn't prevent the many other episodes described in Scripture in which we have sinned and been punished for it. Original Sin isn't somehow different from all those we've committed since. The artist who places her fragile art in the same room with a destructive child, even if she isn't omniscient, probably knows what's coming next. She probably considers the child's actions to be art, as well.