Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to "Ray Kurzweil does not understan...
by jacquesm on Friday August 20, 2010 @05:18PM
(#1621656)
> Taking that as our (relatively wide) target, I don't think protein folding and all that fun stuff adds much information.
It may not add information at all, just as the physical structure of a transistor does not add much information to what a computer can or can not do. In a computer the 'smarts' however are not even embedded in the connections (like what's being posited is the case for the brain), but in the software. Software is state, and software is, to all intents an purposes as good as invisible, unless you find a way to do a dump of what sits inside a running brain.
And then you still have to reverse engineer the computer that that software was running on in order to be able to resume.
Myers DNA length argument is easily disproved by reducing to extremes, if DNA length would be an irrelevant item then you could encode a brain with an arbitrarily short length of DNA, the fact that it takes up as much as it does proves that it is from an information processing perspective not a simple structure. So length is relevant, maybe not the whole story, but definitely a factor.
Part of me wonders if we are going to find one day that the genome does not just contain proteins but also contains the 'boot strap' state required to power up a brain after its initial configuration is complete.
That's highly speculative but there is a lot more data in the genome than what seems to be used and nature never was that inefficient, even if there are many things that could be improved on with the function oriented hindsight that we have.
It may not add information at all, just as the physical structure of a transistor does not add much information to what a computer can or can not do. In a computer the 'smarts' however are not even embedded in the connections (like what's being posited is the case for the brain), but in the software. Software is state, and software is, to all intents an purposes as good as invisible, unless you find a way to do a dump of what sits inside a running brain.
And then you still have to reverse engineer the computer that that software was running on in order to be able to resume.
Myers DNA length argument is easily disproved by reducing to extremes, if DNA length would be an irrelevant item then you could encode a brain with an arbitrarily short length of DNA, the fact that it takes up as much as it does proves that it is from an information processing perspective not a simple structure. So length is relevant, maybe not the whole story, but definitely a factor.
Part of me wonders if we are going to find one day that the genome does not just contain proteins but also contains the 'boot strap' state required to power up a brain after its initial configuration is complete.
That's highly speculative but there is a lot more data in the genome than what seems to be used and nature never was that inefficient, even if there are many things that could be improved on with the function oriented hindsight that we have.