News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing T... by cornholio on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @06:33AM (#16212727)
This sounds too much like the old "man playing God" trope: we don't know, therefore we should continue to revel in our ignorance instead of taking any risks. To hell with that, if I can give my children genes that prevent debilitating diseases and low intelligence and if the risks are manageable, I will take that. That possibility is decades away, but it's a worthy goal to pursue.

This is not about "designer babies" in the eye color or physical appearance sense - who knows what will be the beauty norm 50 years from now. It's about ridding humanity of what we know is deadly and, on a personal level, preventing my own bad genes getting passed on. I have a bad back, an insatiable appetite and high cholesterol, I'm balding and have a slight heart deformity. Should I pass those traits along just for the hope that someday some bald distant sibling will have immunity from a future plague? I don't think I'm really responsible for that, it's the task of future generations to keep the baldness genes in a bank or database and use it at that time if they find them useful.

The reduced genetic diversity is moot - people of all ethic groups have today a chance to reproduce instead of being wiped out like for most part of human history. We are in an explosion of genetic diversity, even very dangerous traits are being preserved in the gene pool due to the advances of medicine that made them survivable. When genetic editing will be so widespread as to threaten the genetic diversity of the human species, we will be living in a Star Trek egalitarian paradise, it's very presumptuous to think we have any foresight into such a future.

Re:China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing T... by andai on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:15AM (#16213302)
> Decades away

Worth mentioning that Iceland has virtually eliminated Down's Syndrome from the population with genetic screening of pregnant women.

Almost all Icelandic women choose to terminate the pregnancy, if the test comes back positive for Down's Syndrome.

Re:China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing T... by cornholio on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:27PM (#16216671)
Not to counter your point, but I was referring to gene editing before implantation and inserting/replacing various traits that maximize the health of the offspring - that is still experimental. Genetic testing and selective abortion has similar end goals but is not a direct application of the ideea.
Re:China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing T... by andai on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:17PM (#16216539)
7 minute mini documentary:

https://youtu.be/S-X97xxw5aI

Re:China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing T... by coldtea on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @06:46AM (#16212780)
>This sounds too much like the old "man playing God" trope

Which was never much discredited in the first place.

Re:China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing T... by cornholio on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:37AM (#16213434)
I see: we aren't having a scientific debate, we have a political disagreement about the place of science in society.