> Engineer, scientist and programmers are probably in an unusual situation - they are exploring a primarily unknown solution space.
This depends on what you are doing. Some programmers are exploring a primarily unknown solution space, and the best programmers probably self-select as this is difficult.
But the vast majority of programmers are busy applying the same well understood techniques to different problem domains.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by jacquesm on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:42PM
(#1621197)
I'm with you on the scientist and the programmer, but the whole purpose of engineering is to work explicitly within the known solution space to be able to guarantee the outcome of their work.
Engineering is applying the lessons of science to achieve predictable results.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by yummyfajitas on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:54PM
(#1621232)
You are applying the term "solution space" in a manner I didn't intend. It's certainly true that an engineer isn't discovering new physics, just as most programmers are not discovering new complexity classes or doing fundamentally new CS. A good chunk of engineering consists of applying existing physical principles in new ways.
Of course, there are engineers building yet another overpass/HVAC/etc just as there are programmers building yet another CRUD app, or scientists sequencing the DNA of yet another bacteria. And now that I think about it, they may make up the majority.
In that case, most pf programming is not so special at all.
Engineer, scientist and programmers are probably in an unusual situation - they are exploring a primarily unknown solution space.
Most jobs live in the well explored, primarily understood areas of solution space, and consist of simply applying already known solutions repeatedly. Teachers, doctors (mostly) and most nurses just perform a set of rote tasks of varying complexity. The best way to improve performance in these fields is to write a script/checklist/decision tree and order everyone to follow it.
(In the case of doctors, I exclude a few at the very high end. Most doctors are not House.)