News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook iPhone app takes OSS code without attribution by btilly on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:18PM (#1621122)
Not so fast. If you include something that someone told you you could, that is a defense against copyright infringement if you are willing to take measures to stop infringing once you are informed of this. (This is the spirit, though not the letter, behind the DMCA safe harbor provisions.)

Secondly there are ways in which someone can write something, truly believe they own it, but actually don't own it. So the question of who has permission is not so simple.

Thirdly the cases I pointed to were arguments about what copyright already covered. There were good arguments both ways under existing legislation and previous case law. The right answer to those questions is based on existing case law, and is hardly simple. (I was caught by surprise when I learned that it was OK in the USA to take someone else's copyrighted binary, and reverse engineer what is pretty much their header file out of it, and include that header file in your own copyrighted work without any kind of attribution!)

There are no comments on this comment yet.