Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by hnal943 on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:13PM
(#1621112)
It is easier. Whether it's better or faster is another question.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by palish on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:17PM
(#1621119)
The whole reason to even list any programming truths is because they would make you a better and faster programmer.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by bconway on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:21PM
(#1621129)
The whole reason to even list any programming truths is because they would make you a better and faster programmer.
Says who? Truths are not always good things. That doesn't make them any less factual.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by palish on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:25PM
(#1621141)
I'd say having a firm grip on reality can only make you a better programmer.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by loup-vaillant on Saturday August 21, 2010 @04:47AM
(#1622492)
You. Not others. If you stop writing bad code, that doesn't stop others to write bad code. That doesn't mean you won't maintain bad code.
Re:Some lesser-known truths about programming
by jemfinch on Saturday August 21, 2010 @09:19AM
(#1622781)
Studies have shown (see McConnell's *Code Complete for citations) that bugs are far new likely to recur in previously buggy code than in code not yet found to be buggy. Since so much time in development is spent in testing and debugging, it's not at all unreasonable (based on studies or on my personal experience) to claim that it's easier or better or faster to rewrite code rather than try to fix it.
This dovetails quite reasonably with Brooks' claim that we should plan to throw one away, because we will anyway.
You had me nodding along until I came across this. This single sentence is not just wrong, it's so wrong that it unfortunately calls the rest of the article into question.