News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:219 days of postmarketOS by TuringTest on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:03AM (#16205375)
May this be the way open source arrives to the masses? As a solution against planned obsolescence?

If people gets used to giving their old devices a second life by lending their old devices to a fellow geek, to install this "weird app" that allows them to keep using it, that could become huge exposure for FLOSS operating systems.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by bacongobbler on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:21AM (#16205531)
It's the exact same story with Windows and Linux. Many old PCs running Windows XP that cannot handle Windows 7's minimum requirements are being wiped by geeks and are installing Linux Mint, Ubuntu, Xubuntu, or some other distro onto these devices.

As long as Linux, postmarketOS or LineageOS are the "weird apps" geeks install for their friends' devices, I highly doubt they'll ever gain any real exposure outside of tech circles.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by JoelTheSuperior on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:22AM (#16205544)
In fairness though I'd say the issue is far less pronounced with desktop and laptop hardware than it is with mobile devices.

I can get a PC from 10 years ago and install Windows 10 and it'll most likely run absolutely fine - really rather well in fact. On the other hand, many people would probably be quite frustrated if they had to use a phone that's even three or four years old.

It amazes me how people react even when I tell them I'm still using an iPhone 6 Plus that I bought in 2015.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by dejv on Monday January 22, 2018 @12:40PM (#16206232)
I am still using iPhone 5S, 16GB and it still works great.

Marketers did a great job convincing people that they need to renew their phones every two years (or less)

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by lucb1e on Monday January 22, 2018 @03:52PM (#16207809)
Galaxy Note 2 here. What are they at, the Note 8 or something? My device just won't die after I put Cyanogenmod on and stopped things from autostarting/wakelocking (battery life is great again).

Just like my bluetooth headphones. I had to re-solder a weak connection twice, but after adding some hot glue to keep it in place the second time, it hasn't broken anymore. The battery life is still better than advertised, and I've been using it daily for 3-4 years.

"Throwaway" is a culture, contributing to the problem just as much as (or maybe even more than?) planned obsolesce.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by greenhouse_gas on Monday January 22, 2018 @01:45PM (#16206766)
It's not marketers. It's that it used to be free (baked into the plan) so there used to be no advantage to not get a phone every two years.

Do while the free phone went away (for this in the cell phone market, did plans get any cheaper?) the purchase styles didn't.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by Fnoord on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:00PM (#16208928)
Problem with iPhone is when Apple decides to pull the plug with iOS support. Android devices suffer from the same problem with their vendor, but then you can flash it with e.g. LineageOS (+ microG if you wanna avoid Google) or postmarketOS.
Re:219 days of postmarketOS by josephg on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:33PM (#16209203)
True; although Apple keeps supporting their old phones for quite awhile. iOS 11 still supports the iPhone 5S, which came out in September 2013. Only 6% of ios devices use an ios 9 or earlier[1].

4.5 years is pretty good in this market - last I checked you were lucky to get 2 years of software updates from most android vendors. According to usage stats about half of all android phones are stuck on an operating system from 2014 or earlier[1]. I don't want to think about the security consequences of most android phones never having security updates installed.

4.5 years still is nothing on postmarketOS's 10 year target. Bravo.

[1] https://developer.apple.com/support/app-store/

[2] https://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by Fnoord on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:40PM (#16209257)
Yes, my mother has that phone (I recommended it) not only does it still get updates it also has a small form factor with the latest one in that family being the iPhone SE. Downside is its expensive to get a battery replacement, and you're probably due after 4,5 years.

Just because phones run an old Android version, doesn't mean no patches get backported. For example, the official firmware for FP2 runs Android 6 with a patchlevel of (last time I checked) Dec 5.

Furthermore, other "postmarket OSes" such as LOS already extend life. The problem with these is firmware updates for chips, and hardware bugs.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by josephg on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:31PM (#16209673)
> Just because phones run an old Android version, doesn't mean no patches get backported.

It’s a bit of a separate problem but I’ve seen an awful lot of ignored software update notifications on the phones of relatives over the Christmas break. Is there data on the install rate of security hotfixes?

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by dejv on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:52AM (#16211574)
I am thinking about replacing battery by myself. It is a bit complicated, but there are guides to do it. Or maybe I get new SE when they get upgraded.
Re:219 days of postmarketOS by SomeHacker44 on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:49AM (#16205789)
I am using the same phone. I just wish I could get Spectre fixes on an iOS 10 release.
Re:219 days of postmarketOS by gcb0 on Monday January 22, 2018 @12:34PM (#16206187)
that's the dumb (sorry) idea that hold Linux on the desktop for so long.

lots of time wasted without any big increase in adoption.

companies making the devices standards (apple, google, samsung) all make lots of money from ads, and subscription services. both of those things get huge advantage if you can lock in your customer.

we are still living the main frame age on mobiles. even if you can install your os on old and new devices, it doesn't matter, because they can cut you out of whatsapp or youtube (see Amazon firephone)

the os is irrelevant to adoption. but it must have the or dictate killer apps. when foss solve IM, social and ugc video streaming, then the personal computer era will begin on mobiles.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by ollieparanoid on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:26PM (#16208597)
Keep in mind that the project at its current state does not aim at consumers, it's looking for fellow hackers who want to join the effort to create a sustainable alternative OS that can be used on phones that would otherwise be thrown away, and simply to have fun while doing that [0].

Regarding the walled-garden services like YouTube or WhatsApp: From a privacy and security point of view it would be better to avoid these altogether and switch to open source and decentralized services like Matrix[1] instead (for instant messaging/VoIP).

I know, for most people it is not feasible to convert all your friends to such services, but even in that situation it is possible to use open implementations that work on Linux. Check out this list [2] ("Apps that only work with proprietary services" table at the bottom).

Going further, when there's enough interest by one or more individuals to package anbox[3] for postmarketOS, it is possible in theory to run regular Android apps (NewPipe[4] is just one example of a great open YouTube client, that you can use on Android today).

[0]: https://postmarketos.org/blog/2017/09/03/100-days-of-postmar...

[1]: https://matrix.org

[2]: https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Potential_apps

[3]: https://anbox.io/

[4]: https://newpipe.schabi.org/

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by TuringTest on Monday January 22, 2018 @01:06PM (#16206445)
But there's the chicken-and-egg problem. IM was solved for a long time, yet the masses didn't adopt the FLOSS version, because that required everyone switching at the same time.

Yet if people get to use the platform anyway as a secondary device, this could get these tools a significant steady user base that might grow to critical mass if/when a security/privacy scandal happens, disparaging the stablished players.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by gcb0 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:09AM (#16214123)
im was far from solved. it was always very hard to find people.

and even then, when the best protocol showed up, google made a point to associate it with gtalk and kill both.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by saagarjha on Monday January 22, 2018 @01:00PM (#16206392)
> companies making the devices standards (apple, google, samsung) all make lots of money from ads, and subscription services

I think that’s only true for one of the companies in your list.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by gcb0 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:10AM (#16214137)
see imusic and ipay revenue projections for apple. and see how much they invested (and projected) for iAd before giving up.

samsung also tried it all. and they make a killing selling pre-installed bloatware in PCs as phones. which is pretty much advertising.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by drdaeman on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:27AM (#16205583)
What would be the reasons to do so?

Ancient devices don't cease to work (unless their hardware fails, of course). They just don't get upgrades and new features (new apps, etc etc). A factory reset (or reflash) may be required to get rid of cruft, then reinstall apps from backup - but afterwards it would work.

If the postmarketOS would offer more features (mostly I think of apps) than some ancient Android, this may be a reason to replace the OS. But I really doubt it would happen. It would require a lot of effort to get anywhere close to Android 4.x ecosystem.

And I believe most users would prefer old apps (downloaded as .apks from random archive sites) to some security patches they frequently don't even know about.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by codazoda on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:49AM (#16205790)
Some old devices do cease to work or they start working more slowly. Apple slows down phones with old batteries, for example, even when they are plugged in. Many of todays devices also require online accounts and some completely stop working when those online services aren't available.

I'm kinda dealing with that with a modern company right now. My Ring doorbell doesn't work without Internet access and I can't get it for 7 days or so. I've got a home network setup, but no Internet. The Ring device won't even ring the bell on my house when you push the button, even though it is wired strait in... Now I'm off topic a bit.

Re:219 days of postmarketOS by alex7o on Monday January 22, 2018 @12:24PM (#16206103)
The main reason for android phons to slow down is the storage, most of the android phones run cheap emmc chips, even some of the more high end ones. Even with a new battery and an AOSP rom, my Nexus 2012 is unusable even when I reverted to the version of android that that tablet came with, which is JB. So I don't believe that this will solve the hardware obsolescence problem.
Re:219 days of postmarketOS by TsomArp on Monday January 22, 2018 @12:27PM (#16206128)
Because of bugs that affect security?