News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to "Ray Kurzweil does not understan... by jacquesm on Friday August 20, 2010 @10:45AM (#1620504)
Think of it as the input to a fractal generator that will expand that input seed in to a physical structure many orders of magnitudes larger than the seed.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to "Ray Kurzweil does not understan... by jerf on Friday August 20, 2010 @12:26PM (#1620813)
For everybody else having trouble with the information theory aspect of this argument: Pop quiz, how many bits of information are contained in the Mandelbrot set? When you figure out the answer to that question, and really internalize the answer, you'll be in a much better position to understand Kurzweil's argument here.

(And forgive me if I think understanding it should be considered a prerequisite to refuting it. Most commenters here are skipping that step. He may yet be wrong, but surely we can at least do him the courtesy of engaging with his actual argument and not dim reflections from a funhouse mirror?)

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to "Ray Kurzweil does not understan... by jacquesm on Friday August 20, 2010 @12:37PM (#1620845)
That was sort of the point, given that the mandelbrot set contains very little real information and that you can express the whole set in one line of math you can take a stab at thinking about the complexity of the structures that you can generate when your input is substantially larger than that.

Find the formula and you have a shot at computing the end result but we're very far away from being able to trace the path from DNA to deep brain structure. Right now we're stuck solidly on being able to figure out the structure of the proteins fast enough (Anton?), once that's more easily done we can move on to the next level of the problem, the interactions of large numbers of proteins in a soupy environment.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to "Ray Kurzweil does not understan... by jerf on Friday August 20, 2010 @01:03PM (#1620914)
By "everybody else", I mean "everybody else not jacquesm", sorry. I am frustrated that you seemed to be the only other commenter understanding it. I was trying to amplify, not criticize. A lot of people are making arguments (without realizing it) that equally well prove we can never compute anything about the Mandelbrot set because look at the amazing staggering complexity it has, except that A: obviously we have and B: the information content is actually quite small.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to "Ray Kurzweil does not understan... by jacquesm on Friday August 20, 2010 @01:21PM (#1620968)
I think that's rooted in the number of disciplines that cross in bio-informatics. Code, reverse-engineering, information theory, math, genetics, chemistry, physics and so on.

It's almost by definition interdisciplinary and I doubt there is any one person that really has the whole view.