Re:The CLARA Method of De-Escalation
by chrisseaton on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:02AM
(#16203740)
I don't understand - do you think it's wrong to leave a critical review? Why should be stop himself leaving them if the product was bad? And whatever difficulties caused a product to be bad are irrelevant in a review of the product. People just want to know if it's bad or not.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The tone matters, I think. Think of how teachers leave a critical review of an assignment, versus the rants you see online. Both are often unpalatable, but the scale of the first kind often seems justified.
Often one feels that one aspect of the product underperformed, while the others were on target, but the reviewers fly off the handle.
Is the review for the benefit of the manufacturer in order to improve the product, or for the benefit of prospective purchasers, to inform them of the quality of the thing they are considering?
Whether a review should be constructive depends on which of these it is.