This might come from years of weight lifting with headphones. There are certain songs, albums, genres that when I hear them it's go time whether it be lifting or working.
So, eg for programming: if it's a problem that's new to me or of notable complexity, music gets in the way. But if I'm hacking together a quick script that's just variations on easy/known problems, I can do it faster with music, and if it's something I'd rather not be working on music can up my productivity by lowering the number of brain-breaks I need to take.
In a completely different direction, for many forms of creative-artistic work, I find music helps massively.
[1] http://relaxedmachinery.com/earthmantra/artist-detail.php?id...
I have experimented with various volumes and types of music while I'm studying, but overall, silence works for me.
For me, the best option is quite ridiculous: I wear a good set of (class 5) earmuffs. Even traffic just a few yards from me is almost silent. I'm wearing a pair right now, actually.
It's just so peaceful. If I could wear these things to bed, I would.
I also only tend to listen to music occasionally, when I 'feel' like it.
The other 25% that requires more mental concentration i need to turn the mute the music.
The 75% typing or something similar is more the bootleneck than anything cognitive so I doubt being musicless would help.
I've also started just using earplugs which can also seem to be (subjectively) effective.
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oh-dcCeR-r4&t=6856s
basically, I search for "cognitive enhancement music"- sometimes the "meditation" ones seem nice, too. I have an immediate relaxation response to this stuff, and it's pleasant.
I'm only distracted by lyrics, but maybe I knew more about music, I'd be distracted by instrumentals.
Personally, I cannot listen to music and work... I get too caught up in trying to follow the music. I end up just wearing my noise canceling headphones with no music playing and working in relative silence.
That said, I'm interested to know if folks here on HN can relate.